Painting the Memories of Home
Jun. 1, 2006
A Loaded Question

Posted in Home Educating

Recently we had a neighborhood cookout.  Now we live in a rural/residential area, so the houses are quite spread out on our road.  For the last year and a half I had never even met our "next door" neighbors.  When I invited one family, the husband said, "So, you want to open pandora's box, do you?!"  That was an attention grabber.  He followed that remark with a long story involving neighbors, water, lawsuits, heart attacks and grudges.  Well, what is a good Christian neighbor to do?  Invite them all anyway!  When the day of the cookout arrived and we had a total of 3 out of the 5 neighbors come.  One family brought a bottle of the cherry wine they'd made from their little orchard.   Everyone laughed and chatted and enjoyed talking for 5 and a half hours!  It was almost midnight and I couldn't believe people were still hanging out.  It really struck me how despite the fact that these folks hardly ever go out of their way to see each other, they were all enjoying a renewed sense of community.  They relived days of 4-H animals getting loose, neighbors rallying to chase other neighbors' pigs.  No one wanted to leave! 

Towards the end, one woman asked me, "So when are you going to let your children go to school?"  The question took me back.  It was one of those that I replayed in my mind the rest of the night and all the next day.  I wish I'd been better prepared for what to say.   My response was an ameliorative conglomeration of military moving, "considering it," nothing against the school, etc.  I definitely didn't want to appear to snub their great school.  Her next line was to inform me, "I think there would be lots of benefits.  They would get a break from you and you would get a break from them!"  Wow....what a combination of statements.  There was really no way in those moments to describe to her our vision.  She wasn't asking, "So, what's homeschooling like?" Or, "How does that work for you guys?"  It was all negative ammo!  After they left, my first reaction was to think, "Man, am I that awful?"

I just couldn't help but think how funny her statement was.  The picture her assumption created in my mind was of my children holding out their arms longingly toward the school and me braced feet wide, with a furrowed brow, holding them back--barring them from the wide open inviting front doors of the benevolent institution.   It's so far from the truth it's laughable.  Our children know how fortunate they are that Mom and Dad have sacrificed time and money and more to give them the opportunity to learn in the comfort of their own home, with great books.  My neighbor implied I was depriving them and this whole homeschooling thing was somehow a way of being weirdly overprotective.  Then the next set of fallacies:  "They would get a break from you."  This mentality holds the assumption that children don't really want their parents' time or attention.  Nothing could be farther from the truth, at least in our family.  If I have to run to the store, everyone is vying for their turn for a trip with mom.  If I read a book, there are at least 3 children wriggling to compete for the 2 sides of my body and the third peering over my shoulder.  Dinner helpers get special secret "perks" while we work together.

      The picture she described conjured up in my mind an image of me hovering over my children every second of the day, ordering them about, micro-managing their every move enslaving them with my presence.  Our lives are nothing like that.  We have order and routine, some disciplined academic time, lots of free play time, time for hard family teamwork and chores and time for family singing and worship.  We don't have 8 hours to waste on chasing after buses, standing in meaningless lines, doing busywork, being poisoned by peer opinions, and then doing hours of homework to facilitate the school's attempts to improve their test scores.  How could I have put that nicely?  Hmmm...

I still wonder. 

Homeschooling is not an incubator bubble for us.  It is the means by which we can "go and make disciples" and carry the torch of faith in Christ to the next generation, how we can learn the ways of Christ in our "going out" and our "lying down" (Deut 6:10). It is the vessel for real life learning, not contrived assembly line products.  It is our training camp where we teach them how to put on the full armor of God.  And if the Lord blesses this endeavor, then when they have done everything, they will be able to stand in the world as beacons and shine like stars.


Post A Comment! Send to a Friend!

Comments

Jun. 1, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by HomeForHeavensSake


This is a great entry! It never ceases to amaze me what some people think... like, as you said, we're holding them back from going to the place they so desperately want to be! *sigh* I guess they just won't "get it" until they see for themselves. Good for you for being such a good representative of all of us homeschooling families!

Bev.


Permanent Link


Jun. 1, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by nsremom


Ya know, before I read your post it never occurred to me how rude that question DOES sound. I just hear it so much. :) When will we LET our children go join the REAL world. The real world in a Junior High? Yeah, right. What's real about that?

Kudos to you for your picnic and NO you're not weird. But even if that neighbor thinks you're weird, really, truly....who cares? You're not doing this to get man's praise, right?


Permanent Link


Jun. 2, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by classykymomma


Wow. Excellent post! I want to figure out how to link.... I'd love to link this to my blog. I love the part about your children clamoring for you, the total opposite of needing a break...that's my life, sista! LOL And I LOVE every minute of it!


Permanent Link


Jun. 2, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by sonshine4u


Don't you hate being tongue tied by questions like that. How many hours and days have we spent formulating our vision and purpose for homeschooling. Fine tuning our reason we even do this. Protecting our hearts from the enemy that throws darts at us when we doubt our calling to homeschool and then you get a question like that! UGH!!! It's frustrating when a person who has no idea what it even means to homeschool comes at you like that.

I think that a lot of people are curious about homeschooling, but lots of people are feeling defensive or threatened by homeschoolers because we seem to enjoy our kids a lot. Hmmmm...while there are days that I want to get out of my house for a sanity break, it seems like all I need is a couple of hours here and there. I hear my little peanuts on the phone and I can hardly stand being away. :)

The bottom line is that while she was being good intentioned from her frame of reference, it jarred you because of her lack of sensitivity to the way of life you have chosen. I think that through time she'll become more curious than accusing and start asking you questions that aren't so "threatening." Then you'll have opportunities to speak into her life through your cool experiences with homeschooling.

I am so glad you had your neighbors over despite the "warnings" of dissention among them. It seems that God places us in strategic locations for things just like this. My DH and I have felt the same thing. We have been introducing neighbors to one another that have all lived in the same cul-de-sac and block for 4-15+ years and we're the new guys on the block! Kind of fun to be used in this way for the Lord!

Keep your chin up and rally around your HIGH CALLING FROM THE LORD!!!

Love ya sista!!!


Permanent Link


Jun. 5, 2006 - wow

Posted by dawilli


Wow, some people...
I've been asked about our homeschooling before, but I guess I really am quite fortunate in that I have never been attacked or cornered into an argument or debate about it. I haven't run into anyone yet who actually thinks it's a bad thing, at least anyone that would say so... but I don't get out much!

It sounds like you handled yourself just fine, most people will see what great kids yours are turning out to be and realize you are in fact doing much more good than harm, some people will just never see that, but their opinion matters very little!

Bravo! for reaching out to your neighbors, sounds like a good time,
ali


Permanent Link


Jun. 8, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by Anonymous


This was a great post!


Permanent Link


Jun. 8, 2006 - Oops!

Posted by Anonymous


I'm on my mom's computer in Indiana and I'm not logged in. Sorry, that was me.
Angel
EEEEMommy


Permanent Link


Jun. 11, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by anewcreation


great post! thanks for sharing! we've barely begun our homeschooling and I have already heard soooo many comments and questions like what you mentioned.


Permanent Link


Jun. 14, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by Lindsey G.


I have to say that I completely love your description of homeschooling! It is something that even though I went to college to become an educator in a school, I am seeing more and more benefits to!


Permanent Link