Confessions of a Homeschool Dad

Sep. 14, 2006

Postmodernism isn't all that modern...

Have you ever heard people argue emotionally?  It's a postmodern technique that says, basically, the feelings / emotions that a person has are true, regardless of fact.

For instance, I was listening to Sean Hannity recently and he played a little clip of when he was "debating" Rosie O'Donnell.  Her entire arguement was speaking loudly, with passion, that something is obviously true.

When asked for proof, she said (loudly, of course) things like, "Do you read?!  Do you read the British papers!?!"  Asked which papers or what stories, her answer was basically that the "facts" of which she was convinced was "everywhere!"

In other words, she didn't have any actual proof for her theories.  She was convinced in her own mind that they were true and therefor - POOF! - they were true.

POSTMODERN DEBATE IN ANCIENT TIMES

This is why it is basically impossible to debate (in its classic meaning) postmodern people.  Debate requires the presentation of a position and then facts to back it up.  Postmodernism has no facts but what someone feels.

I used to think that this was something relatively new.  It turns out that I was wrong.

Back in Jesus' day, as you may recall, the Pharisees were seeking to get rid of Jesus.  And one time, they sent out a crew of people to go get him while he was teaching at the Feast of Tabernacles.  When they came back without Him, here's what happened:


Then the officers came to the chief priests and Pharisees, who said to them, "Why have you not brought Him?"

The officers answers, "No man ever spoke like this man". 
[Confessor Translation: "Gee - He seems to be right about a lot of stuff...."]

Then the Pharisees answers then, "Are you also deceived?  Have any of the rulers or the Pharisees believed in Him?  But this crowd that does not know the law is accursed."
[Confessor Translation: "You morons!  No important people believe Him, so He can't be right.  Everyone that is listening to him has a demon!"]

Nicodemus (he who came to Jesis by night, being one of them) said to them, "Does our law judge a man before it hears him and know what he is doing?"
[Confessor Translation: "Ummmm...you seem to have already convicted Him of something.  Should you, you know....listen to Him and see if He is speaking the truth?"]

They answered and said to him, "Are you also from Galilee?  Search and look, for no prophet has arisen out of Galilee."
[Confessor Translation:  "Are you some kind of moron, too?  No prophet could ever come out of a dirty, rural, out-of-the-way, unimportant place like Galilee!"]
-John 7:45-52


Did you see how they "proved" Jesus couldn't be a prophet because of their feelings about Galilee (which was, back then, sort of the armpit of Isreal)?

Here's the great part in the notes of my study Bible:

"Actually, the prophets Jonah, Hosea, Nahum, and perhaps Elijah, Elisha, and Amos were from Galilee or close to it."

Yeah....but, other than those guys....

Post A Comment! Send to a Friend!

Comments

Sep. 16, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by sagerats
The art of true debate is being lost. It can be hard for so many people to stick to facts with a crazy lunatic screaming in their face. I know for myself that when I am in a verbal debate I can become confused by a person who is yelling and waving their arms about. My mind begins to wonder what on earth they are so excited about. Then I have to concentrate on just what it is they aren't saying. It's not true dialogue, where one person says something, and then the other person says something intelligent and relating to the topic at hand.

Abiding in the Vine!
Permanent Link

About Me

The no-holds-barred confessions of a Christian Husband, Father, and Provider living, working, and homeschooling in Texas.

Recent Posts

Texas Mandates STD Vaccine for 9-year-old Girls
Texas Mandates STD Vaccine for 9-year-old Girls
Passing Out Bibles Now An Arrestable Offense
Christianity and Cultural Relevance
Fun, FREE, Family Christmastime Entertainment
I Know I've Got Pretty Good Kids When...
Anyone Know A Quiet Alternative to Sweeping?
How Many People Would Make An Important Decision This Way?
We Never Realize How Little We Know
Childrens' Innoculation with the American Virus Keeps Us Safe!
Thanksgiving Curriculum Contest!
Debate Test: Your Take on Gay Marriage
Do You Want to be a Desperate Houswife?
Are Women More Easily Led Astray?
This is Just Plain Cool
Resist the Money!
My Last Post on Voting
What is a Husband's Responsibility When Voting?
Is Stem-Cell Research Illegal?
Illegal Heavy-Handedness


Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Email Me
My Blog's RSS

Friends

UndertheSky

TOSPUBLISHER
Tami
julie
ByHisGraceInColorado
spunkyhomeschool
christinemiller
MamaBugs
TeamVeritas
MySmokyMtnHomeschool
wardssward
redmom
crewchief
thehsmomof2
TammyC
Starlady
MrsNehemiah
SteveWalden
lonestaracademy
drewsfamilytx

mrskbrook
FreeStuffForHomeschoolers
Douglas
Melkhi
PRMama
mamaduso
iluvtheland
Sawickis
homy711
glman
sagerats

Amberleoda
JoelKing
FunnyFarm
Amber
LindaI
cricket313
DuctTapeDad
grace4gayle

andrewbaskin
Suzie
OreoSouza

homeskool
jaminacema
PosterGirl
TRINITYPREPSCHOOL
Heidistjohn
Fletch
SupComTabz
askkorndorff
telmar
CommunicationFUNdamentals
vinedesign


homeiscool
Littlebitofeverythingmama
arajbrown
SingingANewSong
jenniferwells

rcelliott
dearmercy
briannash
thisisgilbert
Journalmom
Entry 30 of 263
Last Page | Next Page