Lazy Classical

Oct. 21, 2007

I'm soooo not an unschooler...or a relaxed homeschooler (do I seem relaxed to you? LOL). And yet, it seems we are sort of wading in the gentle waves of the homeschooling sea. Books have been ditched, rabbit trails are being followed, and who knows where we'll end up? We don't really seem to be following anything right now.

I hand Dd(7) a short math worksheet with 12 subtraction problems, with 6 being the largest number. She gets half of them wrong. She added on some. And she even had the MUS blocks at her disposal. The good news is, if they were addition problems, they would be 100% correct. Good thing we've got that addition thing licked. So an interesting discussion kicks up about what would happen if 3-2 became 2-3. I draw a numberline with negative numbers. Dd is interested and follows along. Later, she comes up with some negative problems of her own. Amazingly, she can figure out negative numbers in her head. Weird.

Dd(5) absolutely will not listen to my grandiose teaching scheme which demonstrates tens and ones. Why not? Its fun. We bundle pencils. I even try making tens and ones HORSES. It's not that she doesn't get it, its that she's not THERE, that isn't her interest right now. Nope, she is dwelling in counting-ville. She loves to count. She asks about calendars. She asks about clocks. She asks about thousands and millions and billions. She tells me what 10 + 10 is, and 100 + 100, and 2 + 2. She went on a nature walk with her daddy and brought home fall leaves. She arranged them in order from smallest to biggest and then counted "first, second, third, fourth, fifth". She counts the lanes at the store, and asks about numbers that she sees everywhere. But no, we won't listen to Mom and her "tens and ones" speech.

Dd(7) liked spelling better than any other topic. But eventually she stopped listening to Mom-the-Teacher doing her "phonogram" speech. Which meant she started getting the words wrong. Which meant she now hates spelling and writes sentences that read "This page is stoopid". At least its phonetic. She cries and begs and pleads, "please let me read stories. I want to read. I can learn how to spell by reading, really I can!" And she's probably right. She probably can learn to spell by seeing the same words in her favorite stories. At least at this early stage of learning. I cave. Ok, let's read books. We did come to an agreement, however; for handwriting, she can copy a sentence from her favorite book. I drew up a Perfectly Martha copywork page for her and it has a cute picture of Martha the talking dog on it saying "Soup". She was thrilled. We'll see how long this lasts...

But what all this means is, my school books have been shelved! For now, at least. I'm starting to loose faith in the whole "buy my program and you'll have perfect homeschooled kids" schemes out there. Let's hope I'm not completely going off the deep end here. Afterall, there's standards to maintain, and anti-homeschoolers to impress. Most likely, however, I'll wake up one day soon and say "what on earth am I doing?" and I'll feel behind and pressured. I'll buy Abeka, the complete $500 kit, and then tie my children down to their chairs. I'll crack the whip and make sure the blanks are filled in, by golly! And it'll last about a week, and then I'll cry, and they'll cry, and it'll start all over again.

*Disclaimer: unschoolers aren't bad. Abeka isn't bad. It's all good if it works for you and your family. I really do have "Abeka" type of days. And I have "unschooler" type of days. Hopefully it all balances out and my kids aren't psychologically scarred by it for the rest of their lives:) Its called "a well rounded education" right?

Post A Comment! Send to a Friend!

Comments

Oct. 21, 2007 - Hmm... so I am not the only one

Posted by ThriceBlessed
Lets in a very short three years I have labeled myself, a relaxed homeschooler, a traditional homeschooler, a unit study oriented homeschooler, a classical homeschooler, a Charlotte Mason homeschooler... I finally threw up my hands and declared myself "eclectic".
Permanent Link

Oct. 22, 2007 - Untitled Comment

Posted by Anonymous
Someday's it's frustrating isn't it?

Your little bambino's are so young yet...trust me, it's not a cliche' to say...relax and enjoy them!

I was once standing in your shoes...but worse...I had friends who's kids were the same age (hsing and public schooling) and they were above and beyond where Tommie was....and would brag and compare...it was a nightmare...one friend's child was reading Little House Chapter books in K. Mine barely knew the alpabet!! It was so intimadidating...I felt like such a failure.

Get this...he couldn't identify colors until age 4 and up until 1st grade he couldn't ditinguish between the numbers 10, 11, and 12. UGH!
Eventually, he just got it...naturally....oh, how I wish I hadn't become so angry with him over it, now. I don't recall the dates or exact age when he did...none of that matters now, because well, he knows it.

I am a product of the public system and have the workbook mentality (not that thats bad) and how I wish I could just hand my ds workbook pages all day long to complete on his own...while I sipped tea and scapbooked! But that's not how it works here. I have to work extra hard with games and such to get him to retain things!

"I" am the one resisting this "unschool with a little salt," lifestyle...when I let go...our best days happen and we have so much fun and memories are being made....hence, I renamed my blog, "hedging my bets"....

I hope you find a style that works for all of you...give those girls a hug and take a nature walk!

Your friend, Mich.
Permanent Link

Oct. 22, 2007 - Untitled Comment

Posted by lisaquing
That "buy my program" mentality is what's so dangerous! I think you are doing a great job, Sarah, detecting what is the best way your kids learning and learning to go with the flow of it all. There is lots of time yet for structured learning. I think at 5 and 7 (and still at 7 and 9 and maybe longer!) this approach is very effective.

By the way, I KNOW I learned to spell by reading. And I am a very good speller, not to brag or anything. ROFL And Spelling Power recommends that spelling instruction not begin before approximately age 8 as they are not developmentally ready before that age, so maybe A is onto something! lol I didn't start spelling instruction with David until he was 9 or 10. But Emily was ready at 7-1/2. And she is still better at it than he is.
Permanent Link

Oct. 22, 2007 - Untitled Comment

Posted by lisaquing
In looking back at my comment, I didn't explain well about David and Emily and spelling instruction. He was definitely not ready for spelling instruction at age 8 (or any time before that). So I delayed the start of spelling instruction and provided him with some phonics instruction and lots of reading. He excels in math, but language arts has often been a struggle for him.

Emily, on the other hand, has always excelled at language arts (and, conversely, struggled with math). She showed herself ready for spelling instruction much earlier, and we started her before she turned 8. She tested higher than David right at the beginning and continues to test higher, but I do not attribute this to her beginning the instruction earlier, but rather to her aptitude for language arts in general.

There, I hope that is a better explanation. And now, maybe I should actually go teach something. lol
Permanent Link

About Me

Of all the homeschooling methods, I lean toward Classical; however, I'm not so motivated to do so much work, hence the name Lazy Classical

Recent Posts

My new blog!
Math
Egypt report
Report
First Day Back!

Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Email Me
My Blog's RSS

Friends

Entry 15 of 123
Last Page | Next Page