The Homeschool at Mingo's Corner
Jun. 14, 2006
Veni, vidi... haesiti?

Posted in Subjects of Study

Each time I tackle the "Latin Question," as I've come to think of it, I hesitate. 

 

Should we or shouldn't we study Latin? 

 

Let me clarify somewhat here.  I realize that if we truly want to follow in the classical method, Latin or Greek is a large part of its core.  And I understand that two primary functions of studying Latin is to learn English grammar and to build systematic, orderly, and rigorous thinking skills.  These seem like excellent goals.

 

But then I think about all that time.  The time it takes to teach and learn this language that goes unspoken in most of the world (except the Vatican and as dialects that we call Portuguese, Spanish, Catalan, and others).  Time that won't be spent on other things that seem valuable, like history or science.

 

I also consider the fact that we could learn English grammar, Latin roots, and logic without tackling a language.

 

However, I've determined that my reluctance lies, mostly, in my own insecurity.  I did not receive a stellar grammar education while growing up.  Ironically, I coasted through classes knowing I was missing these bits.  I think I've diagrammed about six sentences in my life.

 

I finally learned a few things about English grammar while taking French in high school.  And I learned a *lot* about grammar while writing my dissertation.  The more complex the sentence, the more important grammar becomes it seems.   It's hard to learn this, though, while someone reviews your writing. 

 

I've resolved to at least give it a try with my daughter.  I definitely want her to have a better grasp of grammar her than I received.  And, the logical aspects of this training will be an added bonus. 

 

I've read that Latin is the equivalent to mathematics for the language arts in that it is rigorous, cumulative, logical, and challenging. 

 

So, with an insecure command of English grammar, the idea that I'll finally have to learn it, using a language I have frequently, if erroneously, been told was *dead,* is a bit daunting.  Maybe even a tad bit annoying. 

 

But, then again, maybe I'll love it.


Comments

Jun. 14, 2006 - Don't let Latin intimidate you...

Posted by InHisName

We study Latin for a whopping 20 minutes a day (+ 10 or 15 of Greek)-- and my three are way better than me at it... but that's ok. We're using Latina Christiana-- and it's not difficult at all.

Permanent Link


Jun. 15, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by Anonymous

I, too, feel ambivalent about teaching Latin/Greek. I am still struggling with this issue. I think it can be very important, especially if our kids grow up to be writers (or other professionals who work with language) or scientists. Let us know how it goes!~ Steph http://momof3feistykids.homeschooljournal.net/

Permanent Link


Jun. 16, 2006 - Hi! We are in the same boat...

Posted by mamma1420

I'm a member of the SOTW1 Yahoo Discussion board and a fellow hsblogger. I also have a 6 year old (she will be in July). I too have struggled with the decision to start latin this year or wait like TWTM suggested till 2nd or 3rd grade. I think this year we will listen to two cds of latin: http://www.sattlerlatin.com/elementary.html and prima latina's cd at this link, http://memoriapress.com/descriptions/prima.htm

The cds are inexpensive and will be fun and just a good way to familiarize you and her to Latin before starting the real lessons. She might decide she wants to do it all on her own. We're still in The Ordinary Parent's Guide to Teaching Reading but we haven't started full-time either. June is our month to visit with family so we're here and then gone...

Come by and visit, I love making new friends!

I also have a Classical homeschooling forum that I created just for us, it's at classicalhomeschooling.forumup.com. We've got plenty of experienced hsbloggers that can inspire, support and provide almost any information about classical homeschooling you can think of. I made the forum b/c there isn't one like it with all the avenues of classical homeschooling explored by experienced homeschoolers.

Nice to meet you! Jessica

Permanent Link


Jun. 16, 2006 - Okay, I'm sorry but I have to say

Posted by mamma1420

I love your website! Your needlework is gorgeous. Sorry to take so much room in your comments, I'll leave now.

Permanent Link


Reviews, comments, suggestions, and other pertinent ideas concerning homeschooling.

View Verse of the Day

What I blog about...

Beginning the Journey
Current News
Galloping the Globe
Homeschooling the Only Child
Issues and Encounters
Teaching Thoughts
On Our Journey
Reading
Reviews
Subjects of Study
Archives

Photobucket Award

Recent Posts

Galloping - Africa
Galloping - South America
Galloping - North America
Galloping the Globe - Polar Regions
Galloping - Europe
Galloping - Asia
Revisiting Galloping the Globe - Introduction
Teaching what matters
Living Books - Comments and a List
Re-entry Blues

Mingo's Best

Mingo's Living Books List 6/24/2009

Blog Links

Home
View my profile
Email Me

How To Homeschool Info
What Non-Homeschoolers May Not Know

Curriculum We're Using Now - July 2009

Artistic Pursuits
Real Science 4 Kids - Physics 1
Latin for Children, A
Living Math
Singapore Math
Primary Grade Challenge Math
Myra Pratt - American History Stories

Other Curriculum We've Used and Liked

Apologia Elementary Astronomy
Galloping the Globe
Sonlight Curriculum
Minimus Latin

Latin Links

Memoria Press Articles on Latin
Teaching Latin
Why Latin?
Why Study Classical Languages

Other Useful Links

Teaching Methods
Step-by-Step Guide to Choosing Curriculum

Mom's for Modesty
Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

What folks are saying about education

20/20's Stupid in America

The Socialization Question

"Socialization: The "S" Word
Your Child and Home Schooling: The Socialization Issue
Home Schooling and Socialization of Children. ERIC Digest
Survey: Homeschoolers New Political Force
How to Answer the Socialization Question Once and for All

And my favorite socialization resource of all:
No Thank You, We Don't Believe in Socialization!

News That Reinforces Our Decision to Homeschool

Abolishing the Honor Roll
Amish School Shooting
Cheerleaders Gone Wild
"Inappropriate Conduct" in the Classroom Withheld from Parents
Principal Sells Meth
Timeline of School Shootings

Some Useful Homeschool Blogs

Homeschooling an Only
It's All About God

Homeschool Blogs I Enjoy

DonnaC
JeannieFulbright
kmathre
SheilaG
cjtredway
Living Life Between the Trees
Playing School
Reaping A Harvest

Entry 44 of 53
Last Page | Next Page


Site Meter