Handwriting: a high priority

Posted in Homeschool Adventures • Jul. 26, 2006

I love to write, and I love handwriting.  So, you can imagine what a shock it was to me when handwriting was our biggest school subject of struggle last year.  My daughter, who loves to draw and paint, hated handwriting. 

 

My solution, after the famed Handwriting Without Tears even produced That-Which-It-Was-Supposed-To-Be-Without, was to drop it.

 

But I am back on the warpath again, so to speak.  I feel strongly that it is time to focus on handwriting.  I was already thinking that, but it has been confirmed this week in that I have had the opportunity to view the handwriting of several children Violet's age or younger, and they are all writing decently.  Violet does very beautiful drawings and loves art, and I know she can do it. 

 

I read through the Handwriting Without Tears Teacher's Manual and found lots of helpful hints.  Most of all, I can see that I will be best off limiting the time we learn and practice to 15 minutes or less and then laying off any criticism the rest of the day.  I have not criticized her at all, I don't want to convey the wrong idea... but it is just that I think I will have a tendency to think that I need to demand perfection all the time on the letters that we have covered.

 

Can I ask those of you who have been through this process a few questions?  1. Should I start with the first book again since we have not been through it and then move to the second, or just start with the second since the only difference is narrower lines?  2. Her pencil grip has been a problem... should I be correcting that at times other than specifically designated for handwriting or not?  I am worried that it will not change if I don't help her with that all day long.  3. Has anyone else struggle with this like I have?  It seems like such a "small" subject to make into a priority; however, I feel that if she does not learn good penmanship, she will struggle to write as she grows up and will hate it.  Also, having taught scrapbooking classes for nearly a century now (LOL), I know that 98.5% of people hate their handwriting.  I don't really want her to be one of them.

 

Please let me know that this will get better!

Thanks!

 


What Do You Think? Send to a Friend!

Incredible Comments


Jul. 26, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by eyecorn
I STRUGGLED, I mean STRUGGLED with DS13 and handwriting from day 1! Unfortunately, I don't even know if Handwriting Without Tears was around 6 years ago. Nonetheless, I wasn't as conscientious as you, and yes, I let it go and was slack. Then, DS got smart enough to say, "Well, I can type everything on Word, so why worry about writing...Look at Dad's signature, look at yours." My advice...stay the course with it, you sound like you're being very cautious of making it an awful experience. I plan to approach handwriting much differently with DD5...I'm going to look into HWT. I look forward to coming back and reading the advice folks have...I need it, too!

Permanent Link


Jul. 26, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by Sisterchicksteph
Handwriting is very difficult for Deuce. He's 7 and has the handwriting of a 4 or 5 yr old. Part of his problem is that he has fine motor issues. We do excercises to strengthen the fingers (playing with chop sticks to pick up small items is one of his favorite things). We also bought special pencil grips because he couldn't get it right. These grips position the fingers right every time. Here's what we have (but there are many out there)

http://www.theraproducts.com/index.php?main_page=product_therapro_info&cPath=4245_4297&products_id=27281

Also, the therapist told us to let Deuce 'wake up' his fingers before starting any handwriting. We have big, resealable buckets full of different textures. We filled one with dry beans, one with rice, one with sand, and one with dry pasta. He digs his hands deep down in and moves them around. The OT says that this makes his fingers realize that they have to do some work, lol. He enjoys it, and if writing gets too stressful we take a sensory break. He can then play in the sand or beans again. This short break makes things go much easier.


Permanent Link


Jul. 26, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by KarenW
My ds had such wonderful handwriting. I was so proud of him. Then along came my dd. Girls are supposed to write neatly, right? Not! Well, I thought her horrible writing was because she was left handed and I didn't really push too much. Then comes along dd # 2 and she is right handed with the same horrible handwriting. Fast forward several years later - ds is 15 and he CAN write neatly but generally chooses not to. DD # 1 doesn't have "gorgeous" handwriting but it is neat and legible. DD#2 (age 8) is slowly making some improvements. All that to say - don't sweat it! Teach the correct formation, work just a few minutes on "handwriting" . I have never done books except for 1st grade and then cursive (which dd#1 started in 5th grade!) Do you do notebooking? With all your scrapbooking experience this should be easy for you to carry it over into homeschooling. Have her work on making a poetry (or whatever) copy work scrapbook.

As far as the grip is concerned, you can buy several different kinds of grips to put on the pencil and they usually help. You might have to experiment with which kind works for her but they are pretty cheap. Does that help at all? I feel like I'm rambling and I have had about 15 interruptions since I started reading your blog!

Permanent Link


Jul. 27, 2006 - Handwriting

Posted by heartmatters
We started off with Italics Handwriting and its led to beautiful handwriting in all my children. Then last year, for some odd reason, I thought I should have my son try cursive, and boy did I mess that poor boy up! It became kinda small and scrawley. So this year I'm going to mend my wrongs and put him back on track. Since he's older, I'm just going to do one semester of it.

Now, many CM'ers would say that if you can't get a lot of quality work, then it's too much work. Give less to start with. ONe sentence. One phrase. Doing their best. ANd then praise them for whatEVER looks great in it. Let the child put a star where she thinks the best "e" is, or whatever. I really like the Italics books.
~jen

Permanent Link


Jul. 27, 2006 - I meant...

Posted by heartmatters
traditional cursive "messed up" my son, not Italic cursive :) He does beautifully in Italic cursive.
Jen

Permanent Link


Oct. 14, 2007 - will it "get better" with Handwriting without Tears?

Posted by Kate Gladstone, the Handwriting Repairwoman
In my experience and observation as a handwriting improvement specialist, Handwriting without Tears definitely produces tears (and worse) for more students than the company wants to admit. For at least some of us, in other words, "Handwriting Without Tears" has not lived up to its name or its claims. (I get a fair amount of my business from kids — and adults — who come to me after non-progress and tears with "Handwriting Without Tears.")

I don't dispute that others report good experiences with "HwTears" (as the web-site calls it: hwtears.com), though I have observed this:

When people having trouble with "HWTears"
(or their parents/teachers)
call the company headquarters for guidance on how to make the program work for them,
the "HWTears" staff members typically instruct the callers to "Please call back when you have success-stories instead. If the program isn't working, that's not our fault - it just means you need to buy even more of our materials exclusively" (or words to that effect).

In one case (personally known to me), when a former "HWTears" user changed to another program and called the company to tell them why, the "HWTears" staff member replied: "If your students ever succeed with any other program, it will all be due to their previous training within Handwriting Without Tears."

To me, such corporate attitudes suggest serious ethical concerns which must make one think twice about dealing with a firm that displays such behaviors.

Permanent Link


Mrs. Incredible/Elastigirl

Home My Profile Archives
Email Me My Blog's RSS


Our Incredible Adventures Meet Our Incredible Family
My mostly random blog about my homeschooling and life adventures with Mr. Incredible and our 3 little Incredibles: 8 year old "Violet", 4 year old "Dash", and 20 month old "Jack Jack".

Our Incredible Adventures

Angela tagged me....
Good intentions aren't enough!
INCREDIBLE NEWS!!!
Busy...
Take 10 to see what's been up with us!

Adventure Categories

Homeschool Adventures
Family Adventures
My Random Adventures
Violet's Adventures
Dash's Adventures
Jack-Jack's Adventures

Incredibly Interesting SitesIncredibly Interesting Sites

Family Fun
The Well-Trained Mind
Well Educated Mind
FlyLady


Our Superhero Friends

See My Friends
Our SuperHero Friends UndertheSky
TOSPUBLISHER
Buckeyeblog
julie
ByHisGraceInColorado
HomegrownHearts
spunkyhomeschool
ClassicalEducation4Me
Sandy
MamaBugs
dartwns
eyecorn
LaMereAcademy
Debi
KarenW
MySmokyMtnHomeschool
DandelionSeeds
tryoneverything
SlackerMom
Cre8iveMom
Aligirl
JavaMama
sagerats
Amber
Pomaleedon
whirlwind
momanna98
KayinPA
Rebeca
GAhomeschoolmom

My4LittleWomen
RollsLife
hrlabonte
smlltwnmmmy

amada
Canadagirl
RugbyHS
BlubberBloggers
Joni
Veronica
labellavita
Lilliepad
Sisterchicksteph
AussieinAmerica

byourlove1
aCleanHeart
missAnonymous
tiredmom

shaffersathome
Lori
wrongwaywendy
themagicschoolhouse
LoriL
timbuck2mom
JustGiveMeStarbucks
buffalorock
stillgrowing
ericaand3kids
linny
HSHubby
homeschoolhighlites
Narniagirl
Darrensgirl
westward
barrellfullofmonkeys
jdbero
samman2007
proverbsmama

Entry 80 of 124
Last Page | Next Page