Little Women

• Feb. 18, 2007 - how praise can actually cause harm to our kids


OK, you have got to read this article!  Smiley    It's a bit long, though  the gist of it is in the first couple pages.  It's one of the most interesting I've read in a long time.

http://nymag.com/news/features/27840/index.html

(If you must have details, it tells of a study which found that telling kids "you are smart" makes them actually work LESS, while saying "you have obviously really worked on this" leads to greater and better quality work.  The amount of difference they found was really staggering.  What they said about how older kids and teens recieve compliments also really floored me--hint:  they think it means something negative!)
Post A Comment! :: Send to a Friend!

• Feb. 26, 2007 - Untitled Comment

Posted by CommunicationFUNdamentals
I haven't read the entire article, but I can tell that they are lumping all gifted children together. Each child is different. I have two gifted children and I can't treat them both the same. Certain things motivate one but not the other.

My dd was told she was smart in private school but was never held to that standard. When I began homeschooling her, I didn't take sloppy work from her because I knew she was smart. I challenged her and she began to give me her best.

My son is different. He looks at things and gets intimidated to try. So I encourage him slowly.

Just telling a child he is smart doesn't do this, it's all the other communication you send as well. Each is a unique child of God and requires handling in his own way.

JoJo
Permanent Link

• Apr. 10, 2009 - Untitled Comment

Posted by dgallew
That was amazing. It never occurred to me that changing the wording just a little would make such a difference.

Thanks,
Darla
Permanent Link

About Me

just chatting, about homeschool, kids, gifted and twice-exceptional issues, etc

Favorite Posts

Lessons from a wedding ring
Review/Comparison: Sonlight and Tapestry of Grace
Comparing ourselves to other homeschoolers
how praise can actually cause harm to our kids
Rethinking discipline, esp for highly emotional kids
Back-to-School Incentive Program
For all those who think everyone else has it all together
If you are tired, GET A SLEEP STUDY!!!!
an informal way to teach children to read
Letting God lead
a tale of 2 fourth graders
Teamwork

Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Friends
Email Me
My Blog's RSS

Friends

UndertheSky
spunkyhomeschool
KAlexaLott
higginszoo
Jjlrdomom
FaithfulGrace
ThreeLittleLadies
MiraclesHappen
ccmmum
Momof5littlewomen
elemenope
sillysiller
CommunicationFUNdamentals
mamatc
amada
BlubberBloggers
mom24seas
Patty7093
MrsIncredible
PumpkinsMomma
Entry 42 of 114
Last Page | Next Page

Blogger Friend School
• TrainingHeartsLeigharev2
ThreeLittleLadies
Isaiah5513
dartwns
ThoughtfulMom
ClassicalEducation4Me
WingsAsEagles
AngelHeart
SheriLynn
kateyz
SlackerMom
INFOJUNKIE
Mom2angels
BChsMamaof3
StitchNchick
mommyto7
timbuck2mom
layla7
ccpeterson
PatinTenn
Roo
sparkshomeschoolmom
FaithfulGrace
kampsplete
LeanneNZ
KarenW
DanielleW
Tinakay
jewls2texas
Galatians69
Victorious
RienzoFamily
tavnkate4ever
semimom
heidim
Bookworm
deedeeuk
oratiomom
MrsStevens95
hutcheson
foxvalleyfamily
ourheartsathome
morelittlewilsons
abiga51
HeartnSoul
thismomiscrazy
Bioluminescence
lilangels
4evrHischild
sunydazy
Sweetie
Bobbi
Sandpiper
MamaBugs
LittleEblingsAcademy
hmschlmomto2
homeschooling6
MOMflippedisWOW
nothinbutgirls
javamama
sagerats
tripletsrajoy
Janne
wadeboysmom
LoriD
youngmommy
mommyof3girlies
twaddlemenot
Diane
MyChildrenAndMe
sunnymountain
aneloo02
floridasnowflakes
OneyJones
Christy
sixsprings
ourhomesweethomeschool
amandasangels
AcrossthePicketFence
NZCate
RobinKelly
jillconnelly
ExcelsiorWarriors
MaxwellAcademy
opheliag
MomOf5LittleWomen
Anerez
acraisydaisy
eclecticinourpjs
mamabear3
MoreLittleWilsons
marybeth
jenn4him
eclecticinourpjs
CanadaGirl
allisalley
fallinglikerain
my4littlewomen