Potty Training • Nov. 15, 2006

 

 

The post so many of you have been waiting for is now here!

 

Potty training is hands down my least favorite parenting task and I don't think I'm very good at it.  But I have learned some things from my children that might be a help to you.

 

I realize that the generation before us claims to have had us all potty trained by 18 months or something like that.  I have had my share of criticism from family members when my two-year-olds weren't trained, so much so that once I said, "You know, if you feel that strongly about it, you're welcome to take her home and train her."  That promptly ended the discussion

 

I wonder if perhaps they feel so strongly about it because they remember the days of cloth diapers and all the work that entailed.  I know my mom has always thought it a lot of work for me to have two in diapers, but I never thought it was any big deal.  If you use disposables, the days of cloth diapering and all it's subsequent headaches are gone.

 

Anyway, all that to say that I trained all three boys at just over two years old.  All three took several weeks, a lot of accidents, and sufficient bribery in the form of m-n-m's to train.  One boy took a full year before he was truly trained.  Ugh. 

 

After the year-long experience, I decided to wait to train our first daughter until she was nearly three.  I also had a newborn, and managing all five under the age of eight meant I just wasn't mentally up to the task.  I was expecting it to be a long, drawn-out ordeal as with the little guy before her.  Much to my surprise, she was completely trained in about four days.  Huh.  Was it just the girl and not her age?  Perhaps.  But when the next little girl was approaching three, I decided it was time she was trained as well.  Two weeks.  Done.  Was I on to something?

 

A few Sundays ago I thought it might be "fun" to put our littlest in training undies for the afternoon.  She thought so, too, especially when the jar of m-n-m's came out.  Lo and behold, this one caught on super quickly as well.  We've had exactly two accidents, neither of them the yucky stuff.  One morning she woke up announcing, "I have to go potty!"  She had held it until I could get her out of her crib and take her to the bathroom!  Unbelievable.  This little one will be three in December, the latest I've ever trained anyone.

 

Certainly, there could be other factors that have led to our success with the last three.  I have relaxed.  A lot.  They are all girls.  But for our household, the potty training motto is now, "The later the better." 

 

Share your thoughts Send to a Friend!


Sharing Thoughts


Thanks for that post, Kendra - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by jannaod
My youngest is turning 2 next week and my mom is already starting the "when are you going to potty train her" questions. My boys trained at a few months shy of 3. My other daughter was 2 1/2. I plan to try after the holidays but I'm not going to push if she's not interested yet. I appreciate the support.
Permanent Link


Poty training - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by misty316
I don't know how you remember what ages you potty trained your kids. It seems to me that it took a long time with my 1st dd I think she was potty trained when she was 2 closer to 3. ( See I can't remember). Anyway my now 21 month old dd I never really decided to potty train her she just wanted to I guess cause she saw her sister going. I never push her to hard I didn't even know that it was possible to get them potty trained in a few days to 2 weeks, lol. She began wanting to take off her diaper and go, when I bought pull ups she completely stopped telling me she had to go, for about a week. Now we go back and forth between diapers and pull ups, (I've heard your not suppose to do that but pull ups just don't make it through the night with her. Plus I don't like having to remove her shoes and pants to put on another pull up while in a store, while trying to keep up with the other dd.
I tried potty training undies right after she started going to the potty, a few months ago, but quickly put those back in the drawer after about 3 floor cleanups.

Pledging to try that again on a day when I would be home all day and could spend the day on my hands and knees wiping up the floor and drying the carpet. Ha!

Now she is even doing so well she tells me she has to potty when we are going down the road in the van. What do you tell a baby that has finally learned what you want them to that they now have to hold it until we get to a bathroom. The other day we had just taken her and got back in the van and at the next stop she said it again, ( just wanted to get out) but what if she really did need to go, don't want to discourage her, but I can't get errands done if we have to visit every bathroom in town, which we do a lot of with my 6yr dd anyway. I get so tired from bathroom visits I often forget some errands and just go home.
Permanent Link


I Couldn't Agree More - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by homekeeper4him
I only have 2 children at this point, but I agree totally with what you are saying. I started very early with my oldest who is a girl. All the relatives were telling me the same stuff. Anyway when my son started getting closer to 3, I just thought he was ready one day. I put underwear on him and he maybe had 2 accidents that week. I was amazed. And everyone told me boys were harder. I tell other mothers just to wait and you'll know when they are ready. :)

Tracy
Permanent Link


you do know.... - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by Jodi
that the psychologist who said we should potty train sooner had 2 kids that were something like 6 years apart (because, of course, that's the ideal psychological age-and no, it was not James Dobson).

Good for you for knowing your children well enough to know when they're ready. Like I tell my friends who stress about this, there is no where on your driver's license or college application where they ask you how old you were when you potty trained.

be blessed,
jodi
Permanent Link


I couldn't agree more! - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by Anonymous
We have 5 children. Without question, the kids that I tried to train around age 2, ended up with lots of accidents and power struggles. Urgh - double urgh. BUT... with the kids that I waited to train (2.5 - almost 3), they trained VERY quickly (in a few days) without much in the way of accidents. At that later age, I feel that they are much more mature and are really ready to learn this skill. They are proud and pleased as punch to be dry!

Incidentally, my 2 1/4 yob INSISTED on using the potty about 2 weeks ago. I tried to distract him as I just didn't want to go down that road yet, but he really dug in in true toddler fashion... he has been moderately successful, but when he became really ill 10 days ago, he was happily put back in diapers (his idea) and there he stays for another while... he's just truly not physically ready - he's too intent on whatever task he's doing to stop and go reliably yet. Suits me to a "T" - we'll tackle in 6 months or so.

So - Kendra - I couldn't agree more! :)
Permanent Link


Untitled Comment - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by Anonymous
I agree to a point. I poop trained myself at 18mo, and so did my daughter. I also have a friend whose daughter trained herself at a year. She refused to let her put a diaper on; granted she is highly intelligent and was talking in sentences at a year. My mom always said 3 was easier than 2. What is boils down to is if the child is ready to be trained, if not you're only parent training.I suppose you could always use the daiperless method!
Permanent Link


This is exactly how it went with my 3 boys! - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by Anonymous
I waited until they were all around 2-1/2 (2 a little earlier, 1 a little later). I just put them into undies and they were all trained in 4 days or less! I don't switch back and forth with pull-ups except at nap or bed time. It seems like they learn they can go into a pull-up and start to get confused. Now, my youngest has just been trained in the last month. He is having trouble going poopy, holding it for 2-3 days before going on the potty. I use candy too! I M&M if you sit on the potty, 2 if you go. Then when they learn how, I switch it to only if you go. Then, I drop it completely. My older 2 boys also got candy when the younger one went, they were very encouraging of him going to the bathroom. :)

Kathy
Permanent Link


Untitled Comment - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by Corin
Woohoo! I'm hoping eventually one of these days I can get the chocolate magic to work on one of mine! If not, I can at least drown my sorrows in M&M's (my favorite candy! :-D )

I'm also glad we aren't the only ones with relatives who all had their children potty trained between 12 and 18 months! ;-)

My first was 3 before he was trained. After 2 months with 3 in diapers I finally said "enough" (we'd been trying to train him for a year). It came down to the whole thing being a battle of the wills (he could stay dry all day if he didn't have a diaper). My husband and I laid down the law and 24 hours later he was trained and even dry through the night!


We're pretty much resigned to the fact that we'll have 3 in diapers again this time around. #2 just doesn't feel the sensation. He desperately wants to be potty trained, but just can't figure it out. I just hang on to something a mutual friend (The L's with Joseph) once told me "He'll be potty trained by jr. high, I promise!" LOL
Permanent Link


Better later - definitly! - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by Dana
Mine were 2 1/2, 2 1/2, 3 1/2 and almost 3.
And I only trained when they could were sweat pants (during cooler weather). That way if they had an accident the sweats caught it at the ankles and I didn't have a mess to clean up.
Oh and my first boy J (at the time 4) trained my second C (2 1/2). I told him if he helped me remind his brother to go to the bathroom, he could have gum each time C went. 4 days later C was fully trained.
Permanent Link


potty training - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by mlbainbridge
I couldn't agree more! I waited until my boys were 3 and they trained with only one or two accidents (night-time took a little longer). My girl was ready at 2-1/2 and trained herself with only one accident...Later is definitely easier at least :-)!!
Michelle
Permanent Link


Yep! - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by Copperswife
" But for our household, the potty training motto is now, "The later the better." "

Wise Words!
Permanent Link


Untitled Comment - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by momanna98
My boys were both 3 before they were trained. One was just three, the other closer to 3 1/2. I thought with my next one I would be more relaxed and just wait. But, my next one was a girl, and she was ready just before her 2nd b-day. Girls are WAY easier than boys. I'm convinced that is the big difference.
Permanent Link


Potty Trained at 3 yrs. - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by Kathy
Both of our older boys (6, 4, & 2) were potty trained once they hit 3 yrs. old. Our oldest just wasn't ready before then, and boy did I hear about it from everyone! I just tuned everyone out when the next boy was 2 yrs. old and not potty trained. I told them my boys aren't ready until they're 3, and that's that. They were both trained in about 3 days. Dry at night and everything! I wish I had thought of your idea and tried to get the "tsk, tsk-ers" to potty train them for me :)

By the way, my niece was potty trained at 2 yrs. and my brother used M & M's. He used them to get her sitting on the potty, but also while she was on the potty if she could tell him the correct color of the one he was holding up both she and daddy got an M & M. That's my chocoholic brother!

Blessings,

Kathy
Permanent Link


Would anyone like... - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by reformingmama
...to come to my house and train my 3-year old son? PLEASE?!?!

This is something I'm not very good at, either. My daughter was trained by 2 years of age, in less than a week. My son could care less. Even M&Ms and lollipops don't motivate him.

This morning as daddy was changing his diaper he said something like, "Buddy, you're three years old, now. You gotta start going potty on the toilet." My son said, "When I'm five I'll go." He's probably right, at this rate.

~Stacy
Permanent Link


Untitled Comment - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by Happyhome
I am attempting to potty train our little girl as we speak, so your post caught me eye. I have had three different experiences with all three of the boys...some easy...some not so easy. Little Emma is just over two and I had planned on waiting. This morning she came to me, handed me a diaper and took off her jammies to have me change her. I thought if she is that smart, certainly she can potty train! That remains to be seen. We had a few accidents this morning, as well as a couple of successes. I'm in no hurry, so it wil be interesting to see what she does. If it isn't working, we'll back off a bit.

Blessings,

Angela
Permanent Link


Untitled Comment - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by timbuck2mom
Almost all my kids were 3 years old too, before they were potty trained. We had very few accidents and they were trained within a few weeks. Most people start earlier then we do but it seems their kids have many accidents before they finally are really and truly potty trained. I'm all for waiting till they are older.

My problem is nighttime wetting. I have older kids that still wet the bed. We've done the alarm and it worked for awhile but then they regress and I think they feel embarassed to wear it anymore.
Permanent Link


Untitled Comment - Nov. 15, 2006

Shared by KimMC
My 1st child was 3 when she potty trained. My second is 2 1/2 and wants to try, so we will soon. If it works great if not we'll try again latter.
One thing I find helps a LOT is to keep a small potty in the van. Then when your going down the road no toilet around the little ones don't have to have an accident if they can't hold it. Espeshaly great with one your just starting to train.
Permanent Link


I couldn't help but notice... - Nov. 17, 2006

Shared by Pomaleedon
...that this entry on potty training is generating almost as much buzz as an entry on when a child should be able to read! ; ) We didn't have familial criticism regarding potty-training; our issue has been shoe-tying. But you know there's always something to criticize! Like penmanship...
Permanent Link


Hmmm don't think I can agree... - Nov. 23, 2006

Shared by Anonymous
I must say it makes sense to train toddlers at later ages...however, I think it makes even more sense NOT to train them to soil themselves in the first place!! lol
Infant potty training is VERY easy as the babies are not yet mobile and once they know how disgusting it is to sit in their own mess they will be more keen to use the potty on their own...once they start walking. Just my thoughts on the matter...my 5 yr old was potty trained the western civilization way and my daughter 7months is being trained now and has very few accidents. But then again I DON'T have lots of children yet either....so we'll see if I continue once I have a quiverful!!
Lori-Dawn
Permanent Link

Home | Profile | Archives
Email | Website



A companion blog to... www.preschoolersandpeace.com



Kendra Fletcher is the homeschooling mom of seven, all of whom have either been, currently are, or soon will be preschoolers.




Categories

*NEW* Family Friendly Recipes
*NEW* Chores
*NEW* Circle Time
*NEW* Training Little Ones
Guest Writers
Life With Preschoolers
Nurturing Mom
Home Organization
School Organization
Musings & Miscellany
Resources

Recent Posts

Bloglines
The Site is Up!
Do Hard Things
Breakfast Cookies
Dontcha Just Love It When...



Preschool Learning
Picture Book Preschool
CCE 1000 Good Books List
10 Things to do Before Age 10
Grace and Truth Books
Rod and Staff Preschool Series
Wee Lambs
Early Preschool Series
Storytime With the Millers

Do Hard Things - Amazon Book Bomb

Hands And Hearts




Click Here for Motivated Moms













































At PreschoolersandPeace.com

Your DayLittle Hands
In The KitchenIn God's House
ChartsQuiet Time
Circle TimeSchool
Resources

Other Helpful Sites

Preschoolers and Peace


Universal Preschool: It's UP to you!


Homeschool Bloggers

Friends Recent Posts
UndertheSky
leebenvic

Lilangels
LaMereAcademy
gmisch
Blessedmommy
belindaletchford
oldpaths
tryoneverything
Hallmark
NancyinCA
lonestaracademy
Hutcheson
Tiany
mrskbrook
eclecticchaos
Panshrmu
mamaduso
iluvtheland
esperanzavallero
MyheartMyhome
lazyd
Moms4Psalms
mistresninos
MommyInTraining
Happyhome
toxicmom3
KimMC
Pomaleedon
rachelle

ElCloud
6formama
momanna98

ChathamMommy
debs02
keldaris

MSAcademy
homeskoolmom

HRTF
Rebeca
dawilli
bumponablog
deedeeuk
genamayo
sillysiller
8isnotenough
CTdittmar
Witness7
Homeschooling6
seekingHim
mamatc
amatthia
juliejo428
mhabrych
jmj403
Dana
shawtime
hallfamily8
DebbieABC
imthinkin
Prncsstefy
hrlabonte

3rsandahug
MarlaMom
amada
RugbyHS
stevewend
Ruach
dadspeanut
SingingANewSong
TrainUpAChild
kidsus8
elkjeld
reformingmama
Momtofivekids
5boys2girls4now
mom2two
AmaniS
HopeandaFuture
teresamatz
ClassicalAstronomy
kaysmarmey
AussieinAmerica
byourlove1
jkk
hopeandafuturecontinued
sunflowermommie
TwaddleMeNot
soon2b5shipes
WomanofGod
ApplesofGold
Bahamahomeschooler
momco3

KaneFamily
Leigharev2
KerryLeighinNC
InfertilityMom
my6davidsons
booknhome
timbuck2mom
sistertosister
Victorious
4kiddos4me
ForSuchATimeAsThis
my2kids4Him
MarineMama
hindsfeet11
My3BoysHomeschool
linny
BChsMamaof3
youngmommy
jannaod
TKDMomma
Dechertimes2
jengresak
tryonis
hadleychick
Staysee
mamabear2003
AnneShaw
mommyof3girlies
Darrensgirl
misty316
Mommygirl3
westward
crazybusy
AmyD
2lilcountrybumpkins
mom2kateandella
4realblessings
FruitfulFamily
scarver
KiwiSmithFamily
LivingByDailyGrace
ltjewel
MyLittleLammies
babean
HandsRaisedToHeaven
4sweetums

Joyfulhomemaker
jessjjordan
keelie97
AutumnTerrill
kristigirl444
Beechnut

jabbabean
pottershand
SweetSavages
deovolente
innovativelearning
joyfulmomy
teachingthegoodmans
barrellfullofmonkeys
thesuparats
baronsgirl
dadspeanut3
sdtorres
BelovedPeace
cahanbury
mountainsong
RDFLEMING
SchoolinRhome
ckbagby
PeterRabbitPreschool
dawnz
thornfaith
Waldens

homekeeper31
newcr8ion
sixfolks
tearinn
JADsmama3
learningatourhouse
Clemons

Other Friends

themangotimes
tenthstreetplace
beccaskitchenwindow
largefamilylogistics
QuietLife
Copperswife
HolyExperience
At Granny's House


Photobucket


Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting


Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting














This Weblog Made Beautiful by:





Every Word I Write Here is Copyrighted (c)2008 Kendra Fletcher. For reproduction permission, please contact Preschoolers and Peace at the email address above.