There and Back Again

Saturday

'The Return of the King' Critique

 

            Legolas and I finally finished reading the Lord of the Rings trilogy by Tolkien and so last night we had a party and watched the movie, "The Return of the King" for the first time. I was very impressed with the special effects and the acting. They played their parts very well and almost all of them looked pretty much how I imagined them. I thought that Aragorn was wonderful. He was so kingly and calm, and yet, he was a warrior and a ranger as well and he knew everything about fighting and the wild.

            Legolas was great, too. I really liked the scene where he climbs up the arrows on the elephant's back and cuts the rope that holds the whole group of Southrons. He was certainly never afraid of anything. Gandalf was fantastic! He was the perfect emblem of good and even when Denethor had despaired and called the retreat, Gandalf kept fighting.

            Having read so much mythology where the heroes go to the realms of the dead, or the underworld, I thought it very interesting that Aragorn went through the Paths of the Dead, inside the mountain, to summon the oath-breakers to fulfill their oaths

             I don't think that the script was as good as in the other two movies. There were not as many good lines and I got the impression that the movie-makers got tired of making the movie and rushed through the last part without stopping to think of some really good lines. For instance at Aragorn's coronation I expected him to say something a little more stirring and magnificent. He should have made an admirable speech that could really encourage his people.

.           In the book, Gollum did not deceive Frodo like he did in the movie but I think that the movie shows just how base the ring had made Gollum. He told Frodo a bunch of lies, promised not to harm him, but then he deserted him in Shelob's cave to die. It also shows how the ring blinded Frodo to the truth so that he chose a slinking, skulking, sneak like Gollum over Sam, his best friend who loved him and was even giving him his share of the food and water. Sam was an incredible hero to push through to save Frodo even after Frodo sent him home and went with Gollum and, in the end, Frodo realized that Sam was his real friend when Sam risked everything to rescue him in Cirith Ungol.

            I thought that Peter Jackson did a great job portraying evil and how ugly it is. He made the Orcs simply disgusting and as soon as I saw Minas Morgul, I knew that it was evil. The contrast between good and evil is so sharp that when you look at the battle scenes, you just know which side is evil and which side is good.

            Overall, I really enjoyed the books and the movies. The books are very well-written and the movies are incredible, too. They are full of adventure and they inspire you to be a hero in this life. And they teach us that fairytales really are true because one day the King really will return.

 

Frodo

 

 

• Post A Comment! • Send to a Friend!

Comments

Sunday - :-)

Posted by BookFreak
I'm glad you got to see the third movie! I really liked the first because you really got to know the characters... even though i already "knew" them because of reading and re-reading the books! I wasn't sure if i liked the third movie quite as much the very first time i watched it because i was upset that they edited the raising of the shire! That was my favorate part of the books! But I've forgiven Peter Jackson now just because they're all such good movies! (Not to mention books!)

Well, I'm sure that you get a lot of comments on this but... how did you get your music onto your blog? I've downloaded several songs off of my CD's onto our computer but i can't get them into HTML format to put onto my blog!
BookFreak:) :)
• Permanent Link

Monday - Untitled Comment

Posted by Anonymous
Yes, I should know the butterfly if you send me a picture. Thanks,

Jonathon
• Permanent Link

Tuesday - Good review!

Posted by Jocelyndixon
I think I agree with EVRYTHING you said! I don't think there is much more to tell! I love the books and admire Tolkien for being such a great writer and I love the movies and admire PJ for being such a great movie-maker! I don't think anyone could have made the mvies better and I probably wouldn't have gotten into LOTR if it wasn't for PJ.

I should be sending you a rough-draft of "A long road" shortly...

I tried to find out what that Butterfly was too, but had no luck!

With much love and admiration,
Myrtle, a Hobbit from BloggerEarth
• Permanent Link

Friday - Untitled Comment

Posted by Gollum/TheEntomologist
I don't know what kind of butterfly that is, but I'll ask my Dad. That was a very good post about the ROTK movie.
• Permanent Link

Tuesday - Untitled Comment

Posted by Ringbearer
Thanks for all the interesting comments!
• Permanent Link

Our Quest

"All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to us..." GANDALF

The purpose of this blog is to record the ideas that are most important to us. We are two sisters who choose to go by the names of Frodo and Legolas. You will find poems and quotes, narrations and pictures from our favorite sources that have inspired us to use the time that has been given to us to the best of our ability. We hope you will enjoy the journey there and back again....

Frodo and Legolas





bagend_mov

Bag End

• Home
• View Our profile
• Shire Archives
• Our Blog's RSS
• Frodo's Sketches




Beyond The Shire

•
• Lord of the Kingdom
• Arwen Undomiel-our favorite LotR fan-site!
• Our Mom's Neat Blog
• Skopeo Literary Society
• Blogheader Artist
• What's Your Middle Earth Name?
• Beyond The Loneliest Star
• God in the Bush
• Earth is Crammed with Heaven


nominee
BEST TEEN BLOG




TheRebelution.com: Enlist Today







Bilbo_EE_2

Bilbo's Bookshelf

• About the Land of Turkey
• Book Reviews and Movies too
• Poems worth Reading
• More Poems worth Reading
• Languages
• Science
• History
• Art
• Stories
• Nature Notes
• Deep Thoughts
• More Deep Thoughts
• Flotsam and Jetsam




frodobook2

Frodo is Reading...

• The Birth of Britain
• The Brendan Voyage
• Beautiful Girlhood
• The Lay of the Land
• Ivanhoe
• Trial and Triumph
• Age of Chivalry
• Fearfully And Wonderfully Made
• How to Read a Book
• The Story of Painting
• Life of Nicias by Plutarch
• The Silmarillion
• The Final Quest
• A Taste of Chaucer
• Joan of Arc by Twain
• Idylls of the King
• Much Ado about Nothing
• A Wrinkle In Time
• Life of the Spider
• How the Heather Looks
• Pursuit of God
• Daughter of Time
• In Freedom's Cause
• Lilith
• David Copperfield





legolassparklesnowavatar

Legolas is Reading...

• The Silmarillion
• Halliburton's Book of Marvels: The Occident
• Age of Fable
• Life of Nicias by Plutarch
• The Story of the Greeks
• Augustus Caesar's World
• The Sea Around Us
• Hittite Warrior
• Animal Farm
• Magician's Nephew (in Turkish)
• Archimedes and the Door of Science
• Swiss Family Robinson
• What Katy Did
• Unfinished Tales
• Where the Red Fern Grows
• Follow My Leader
• Penrod
• Story of the Romans
• Along Came Galileo
• Jack and Jill
• Never Give In
• Valley of Thorns (in Turkish)
• Ben Hur



ttt_gla_glb

The Fellowship

• BlogBoy
• Cornflower
• Mariel
•
•
• Kalene
• Eyebright
• IceJet
• Boomer
• OutdoorGirl
• KayinPA
• opckid
• Gollum
•
• HRTF
• Inklings
•
• BookFreak
• TheEntomologist
•
• arwengirl
• Kekoa
• rjdjohn316
• Jocelyndixon
• SuperAngel
• barbieheart
• JacqueDixonSoulRestES
• Creator
• Ruach
•
• roaringkitten
• antelopehead
• bushkins
• PevensieGirls
• mandygrace
• Lukelee
• riverthomas
• RockStar
• youwithoutme
• sleeper
• Isaiahstorm
• TheLordsDaughter
•
• MerryandPippin
•
• totustuus
• Chris
• SingaporeGirl
• AuthorElf
• VirtuousMaidens
• Rose
• BrielleCostumes
• MyrtleDimpleOfHardbottle
• EldestOf5
•
• longleggedgirl
•
• LeviDen
• melon
• mainekid1
• pixiedust
• nancysnook
• GirlofGod
• Sparkles
• LifeSong
• CamtheMan
• Bluejane
• Sweettunes
• POTCgirl
• Altariel
• stillsmallvoice
• gwyndolyn


tolkien

The Myth

"The value of the myth is that it
takes all the things we know and
restores to them the rich
significance which has been hidden
by the veil of familiarity . . .
By putting bread, gold, horse, apple
or the very roads into a myth,
we do not retreat from reality:
we rediscover it. As long as the
story lingers in our mind,
the real things are more themselves.
[The Lord of the Rings]
applies the treatment not only
to bread or apple but to good and evil,
to our endless perils, our anguish
and our joys. By dipping them in myth
we see them more clearly. I do not
think [Tolkien] could have done it
in any other way.”
- C.S. Lewis


frodoglobe


The Music

INTO THE WEST by Yulia



The Movie

LORD OF THE RINGS
The Return of the King




'When the seas and mountains fall
And we come to end of days
In the dark I hear a call
Calling me there
I will go there
And back again'


Banner


The Books




Subscribe

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


Homeschooling

Entry 115 of 171
Last Page | Next Page


wedding