Saturday, March 18, 2006 at 7:41 AM
Thinking Outside the Egg Carton
Posted in Homeschooling
Have you ever looked at an egg that youve gotten from the supermarket? I mean, have you looked closely? These eggs have been carefully picked and screened for color, size, and quality. Theyre supposed to look the same. And yet, even these eggs have subtle differences to them. One is a little more oblong than the other, or one has more texture than the next. But still, theyre all supposed to be the same. While we may crave uniformity, we must force that uniformity on uniquely created products.
In every classroom in America, dozens of neatly arranged desks sit row upon row like egg cartons. There is a tip of the hat or two to a childs individuality, such as a name on a desk, but really it is just assumed that every child is the same. Your child is the same as my child. Theyre expected to sit orderly in their seats all day, with periodic breaks, of course. For all children should give the same answer, all children should talk the same way, and all children are supposed to learn the same way.
That is the theory, anyway.
In reality, children and eggs are uniquely created. There are small, brown ones, jumbo, white ones, big, brown ones, and even a few speckled ones. They dont look the same because they arent the same.
Children are even more unique on the inside. One child is as unique as the next, with likes, dislikes, thoughts and actions that are different from everyone else in the world. And yet our culture thinks we should stratify our children into layers called grades and cartons called classrooms and make sure they all fit the mold. Why? Because thats the way the system works.
My children are different from Grade AA Fancy Extra-Large. In fact, Im not sure that theres even a name for my children beyond the ones Ive already given them. They are uniquely designed, uniquely created and they uniquely learn at their own pace. My son may not learn music or history as quickly as my daughter. Does that mean he has to keep going until he masters it? He would if I was trying to turn out every child the same. But this would be a great disservice to him. Instead, he deserves every shot at music or history, but if his talents lie in math or language, its unreasonable for me to base his performance on some prototypical renaissance child that can do everything equally well. He is the best at being himself, and my goal is to make sure that he gets the chance to make the most of it. While I need to know where my child's strengths lie by grading his work and helping him improve, I will not push him to get straight A's or even straight B's. I want him to find his passion and follow it.
Comments
Saturday, March 18, 2006 - Thinking outside the box
Posted by OurLittleSchoolRoom
Thanks for the reminder of the uniqueness of our children. It is so tempting to push our children when one isn't as quick, or as bold, or...anyone can fill in the blank. It is time to accept them for what they are--precious, unique individuals, and a gift from a loving God.
Blessings,
Karen
Permanent Link
Saturday, March 18, 2006 - Hmm
Posted by lostcheerio
I think I spend 99 percent of the time glad that my children have strange angles and protuberances that prevent them from fitting into the nice oval slot. Glad that I keep them home where they can be surprising and unique and not get it all rasped off for the convenience of the system. However, I must admit the one percent of the time (or maybe 2 percent) that I spend wishing they were a little more oval. :) :) :) Just THINK how nicely that little egg crate would close! *cackle* JUST KIDDING. But... :)
Permanent Link
Saturday, March 18, 2006 - Amen.
Posted by schooldad
I love the fact that my kids are unique. I want them to thrive on the fact that they are not created by God to be like anyone else... that they are wonderfully and fearfully made.
I make it a point in our family devotions to talk about God's purpose for their lives and not to judge themselves by anything or anyone else they see. But to look to God, in prayer, for what He created them for.
My son is an extremely fast learner while his younger sister likes to take her time. It would be going against God's design for them for me to push them into someone they aren't.
Thanks for the post and for the great thinking that comes from it.
Permanent Link
Tuesday, March 21, 2006 - Thank you
Posted by cudltot
For reminding me that my kids are unique. That it is ok to approach homeschooling differently with each of them. This is something that I have been struggling with.
Chrissy
Permanent Link
Tuesday, March 21, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by writmm
A great reminder. I have raised two stepsons and am raising two of my own children now and each are very different and they had the same parents and grew up in the same environment!
It amazes me how our schools try the one size fits all theory and then can't figure out why it isn't working for them.
Permanent Link
Tuesday, March 21, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by Carrie K.
Very well said.
Carrie K.
Mommy Brain: http://carrie.homeschooljournal.net/
Permanent Link
Tuesday, March 21, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by tootlepiptoo
Great post! Thanks for the reminders.
Permanent Link
Tuesday, March 21, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by gal51
We get our eggs from a free-range farm. The chickens are allowed to be, well, chickens :) ... and the eggs are all different colors and sizes. And they taste better and are also more healthful than "government" approved eggs ... what a great analogy that I have never thought of before!
Thanks and Blessings to you!
~Heather
Permanent Link
Tuesday, March 21, 2006 - Yep
Posted by SteveWalden
I was hoping someone from a farm would chime in about eggs and their different colors and sizes.
Thank you all for your comments!
Permanent Link
Wednesday, March 22, 2006 - You're perspective
Posted by Meredith
Excellent perspective and insight, love the egg analogy too!! Great to hear a dad's side of the story on raising & home educating children, thanks.
Permanent Link
Wednesday, March 22, 2006 - Reprint this post?
Posted by Deborah
Hello, Steve!
I am wondering if I may have permission to reprint this post? I am collecting short articles on a "blog"of sorts, hoping to come up with several hundred to evenutally send out via daily emails. If given permission, I would cut and paste your article along with a link back to your blog here:
www.educationbeginsathome.blogspot.com
Deborah
www.onebeggarsbread.blogspot.com
Permanent Link
Wednesday, March 22, 2006 - Sounds Great...
Posted by SteveWalden
Sounds great, Deborah. How do I get in touch with you? You can e-mail me at dadscorner@gmail.com
Permanent Link