Thursday, April 6, 2006 at 9:57 AM
Doctors, Check-ups, and Percentiles
Posted in Homeschooling
Marsha's blog about development got me thinking.
It's amazing, the powers that doctors have. They can analyze your child and determine, usually, what's wrong and prescribe a form of treatment. We have gotten so used to this that we just assume that the doctor's word is golden on anything they say.
When my firstborn daughter was in for her wellness check-up, they measured, poked, and prodded our baby girl and promptly announced that she was in the 94th percentile for head size and the 10th percentile for body weight. That's what they said, but the impact was much akin to the lines from a movie from the early 90's that I remember, "your kid has a huge noggin! It's like an orange on a toothpick! It's a virtual planetoid...with it's own weather system!" I came out of the office wondering what was wrong with our child and what we were doing or not doing to cause it. Only weeks later would my wife and I discover that those percentiles were virtually worthless. They told you very little about the health of your baby.
Parents, especially new parents, tend to obsess over "normal" when it comes to their children. Doctors sometimes don't understand their power when they tell parents that they're "concerned" about their child's development because he only knows a few words or he hasn't started rocking, crawling, walking, or leaping tall buildings at the right age. Parents can feel like it's up to them to save their child from a life of mediocrity by pushing him to catch up with "normal."
One of the pastor's families at our church gave birth to a baby with Down's Syndrome. They really love that little guy and call him "Peanut." After the diagnosis, at one of his first wellness check-ups, the doctor began handing the mom sheets of paper with all the data of what she should expect for a child with Down's. He was going a little quick and just as she was beginning to feel overwhelmed, he stopped, took the papers out of her hands and said, "Here, now these things are for me. Your job is just to love your son. I will worry about these papers. You don't need to deal with them." Imagine if she had left the clinic with the papers in her hand. By taking back those papers, the doctor was freeing her to be a normal mother with her son.
Are there times to be concerned about a child's development? Sure, but not nearly as often as parents are needlessly worried over their child "falling behind." Every child is different. Even if they fall behind by years, as I did in my own development with reading retention and comprehension, it is not a judgement sentencing the child to sweeping up at McDonalds. The human brain and body are resilient and can make up the difference a lot of the time. The kid who nearly failed his gradeschool education because of his reading disability is now a professional writer. Patience, wisdom, and, most importantly, prayer will help you as you teach and guide your children. Trust God, your child's Creator, with their development, and
don't panic.
Comments
Thursday, April 6, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by mistresninos
I'm going to pass this along to a friend. Thanks.
• Permanent Link
Thursday, April 6, 2006 - I'm that friend...
Posted by BelovedLamb
...and boy did this hit me where I'm living right now!! Definitely printing this out!!! Thank you for sharing!
Amy
• Permanent Link
Thursday, April 6, 2006 - Normality
Posted by Anonymous
Steve, Russ here...
Very touching piece...fits very well with "homeschool expectations." How often do we allow outside influences to ruin our days? Drs, anonymous "terror alerts," media, on and on and on. Thanks for centering.
BTW "Normal" is just a setting on your dryer.
cheers
• Permanent Link
Thursday, April 6, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by eyecorn
My brother in law is a pediatrican with impeccable credentials and experience...
His take on doctors, "Oh, there are a lot of great ones out there...it's the other 98% you have to worry about."
• Permanent Link
Thursday, April 6, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by spunkyhomeschool
I liked this post. Very well said. Thanks for the reminder!
• Permanent Link
Friday, April 7, 2006 - I'll Never Forget...
Posted by Unique
My anatomy professor told me, '50% of the doctors graduate at the bottom half of their class'. :D
Listen, ask questions, do research, and make up your own mind. Jesus still does miracles, yes, even in this day and age.
• Permanent Link
Saturday, April 8, 2006 - Thanks!!!!
Posted by momof2
Thank you for this, I really needed it.
My 8 year old has trouble with reading and I know that I worry about it way to much.
Thank you again for the reminder to just turn it over to God.
Naomi
• Permanent Link
Monday, April 10, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by Amber
This is such a great post, thank you! You should think about submitting to the carnival, seriously. I really hate to call the doctor for this very reason. They make me worry when there's no need. When my youngest was born they said I needed to make an appointment when he was not even a week--they changed the law, it used to be 2wks old. Anyway, they said he had janduise (I have no idea how to spell it). All my children had it slightly, but by time 2wks came by it was gone, so of course a few days later he still has it in his system, about 70% of babies do...or so I'm told. Everyday for almost a week, he had to be torchered and get his blood drawn (from foot) and guess what, a week later he was fine. If I had taken him at 2 weeks like I did in the past, he would have never had to go through that suffering. I can't help but wonder, are doctors really taking these precautions because they are concerned, or bcz they want to make another buck!
Sorry for rambling.
God Bless,
Amber
PS~ Does your wife blog?
• Permanent Link
Monday, April 10, 2006 - Thanks
Posted by SteveWalden
Thanks, everyone. I'm glad it spoke to you.
No, Amber, my wife does not blog, unfortunately. She says I'm the writer of the family. Maybe I can convince her in the future...She's very wise and loving, two things that are needed in the blogosphere.
• Permanent Link
Friday, April 14, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by Anonymous
Hi Steve,
You said, "Only weeks later would my wife and I discover that those percentiles were virtually worthless."
How did you discover that exactly?
Thanks for the post, by the way. My little girl (17 months) has a big noggin too, but I think it's going to be OK.
Casey
• Permanent Link
Friday, April 14, 2006 - Casey...
Posted by SteveWalden
It was quite a while ago, but we talked with an RN and another health professional that said the percentiles weren't much to go by in terms of determining your child's future or overall health. I'm not saying that they're entirely worthless, but I think that doctors shouldn't bring percentiles up with parents unless they're concerned about a something else that they want to test for.
• Permanent Link