Susie-Q&A

• May. 9, 2006 - Tales from the 50's

I saw a good movie this week (on my mother's recommendation):  The Prize Winner of Defiance, Ohio.  Took me two nights to watch it, since I'm trying to get to bed earlier these days.

 

Set back in the days when homemakers really knew their stuff, this is the true story of a mother of 10 (played by Julianne Moore) whose husband spends too much of their income on alcohol.  She literally feeds and houses her family by her wits, writing jingles for contests.  Many prizes come just in the nick of time, getting them out of some very difficult scrapes.  I haven't read the book and I don't know how much of the suspense can be chalked up to dramatic license, but her skill and good fortune were truly amazing.

 

Evelyn's stoic cheerfulness in the face of many disappointments would be almost unbelievable, were it not for the final injustice that does her courage in later in the film.  Her indomitable optimism and will to be happy are inspiring.  I loved the scene where she comforted her little daughter, who had made a big mess trying to change the baby, by showing her how the delay actually bought them some time in a problematic situation, so it was "meant to be."  

 

And speaking of that problematic situation, I wonder if their real-life milkman was as annoying as the one in the movie, or if that was another little bit of dramatic license.  If he was, he certainly deserved to be immortalized as a jerk on film!  The father was somewhat sympathetically portrayed, but he does come off as terribly irresponsible at best, and downright mean at his worst times.  Woody Harrelson managed to evoke pity for his character.  I imagine it would be hard on any man's ego for his wife to have to be the breadwinner because of his faults.  Evelyn's gracious ability to soothe him is amazing.

 

The vintage look of the film really adds to its charm.  It feels like a trip back in time. 

 

Unfortunately, the feminist myth of the subjugated 50's housewife is detectable, as well some stereotyping of the Catholic church.  But the film does transcend these defects, especially by giving us a glimpse of the real children, Evelyn's real legacy, at the end.  I recommend it!

Post A Comment! :: Send to a Friend!

Comments

About Me

Heavy on the Q., light on the A., and trusting God in between them.

Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Friends
Email Me
My Blog's RSS
Hugh Hewitt
James Lileks
National Review's The Corner
The Thought Train
LaShawn Barber
Allthings2all
Guilt-Free Homeschooling
Homeschool Buzz Blogwatch
Dawn Eden
HSB Company Porch
The Dawn Treader
Decent Films Guide
Freeman Hunt
The Rabbit Hutch
The Kissack Family
C-SPAN
Real Learning
Winsome What-Nots
Homeschooling Radio Show
The Point (Breakpoint Blog)
Wittingshire
Gagdad Bob
Get Religion
The News Right Now
The Sacred Cow
My Utmost for His Highest
One Place
Our World
Mrs. Mobunny's Blog
The McGarveys
Vital Signs Mostly Stable
Catrina's Blog
The King Family Blog
Amy's Humble Musings
The Doctor Is In
"Jazzy"
The Pioneer Woman Cooks!
Mere Comments
TeamBettendorf
The Ballards' Blog
Like Merchant Ships
Successful Homeschooling
Blink Link
William Katz
The Mom with Brownies
Our Pond Blog
No Idle Hands

Friends

ClassicalEducation4Me
CreativeHomeschooling
christinemiller
JeannieFulbright
Keepermom
Harriette
jayfromcleveland
creech7s
mrskbrook
Melkhi
sewingfanatic
AndreaGale
MotherJoy
TC
mom2rebels
goodwifeh
heartathome
momachasity
dawilli
heartwomb
sajolley
amlp311
shaunms
barbieheart
ABlessedLife
CarpeBanana
TribeMommy
Jesus1st
JustaSEC
HisAbidingLove
purityseekers
Mamalama
4sweetums
msmarla
JenniferAppling
Rivergallery
ChristLover
salsaandtea
Entry 904 of 1234
Last Page | Next Page

Tomato Growers Blog Ring

Free Site Ring from Bravenet Free Site Ring from Bravenet Free Site Ring from Bravenet Free Site Ring from Bravenet Free Site Ring from Bravenet Site Ring from Bravenet

Tomato Growers Blog Ring

Free Site Ring from
Bravenet Free Site Ring from
Bravenet Free Site Ring from
Bravenet Free Site Ring from
Bravenet Free Site Ring from
Bravenet
Site Ring
from Bravenet