Lilliput Station Adventures

September 10, 2008

How We Use Narration

Posted in Homeschooling

I didn't set out to be a "Charlotte Mason Homeschooler." I'm not one of those moms who researched all the various methods before choosing the perfect one. In fact, following someone else's method of teaching goes against what I believe is one of the greatest benefits of homeschooling- education which is tailored to the needs and styles of the learners. But over time I have discovered that many of the things which I began doing simply because they worked, were things which Charlotte Mason also used. One of these things is narration.

 

With our large family, it has always been easier for me to teach the children as a group whenever possible. Science, geography, and history have always (up until this year) been done together. Even the toddlers sit in on these lessons. The young ones are often fidgetty and it is sometimes hard to know whether they are actually listening. In order to make sure they pay attention, I stop often to ask questions. Thus, my children end up narrating throughout the lesson. When we have finished our reading, I ask one or two of the older children to tell me what we just learned. This gives the little ones a chance to hear the material one more time (they usually listen better to brother or sister) and they often want to add their own narrations as well. Having the children do narrations offers them an opportunity for friendly competition, as everyone wants to be able to mention that one important fact that everyone else forgot.

 

I think the problem with using the term "narration" is that it takes something that is really very simple and makes it seem more complex. To me narration is nothing more than having a discussion about something you have learned. It is a tool for measuring learning, not a permanent record of that learning. It is a memory shared between two people, not something that must be recorded for all posterity. Most of the time I don't require a written narration, especially if the child is still learning to read and write. However, since my oldest three are working on their own this year, they have been doing more written narrations. I still feel it is my duty to respond to these narrations, to guide them with more questions if necessary. That way we can still have that "discussion", even though it is on paper rather than being spoken.

 

If you'd like to learn more about narration, you may be interested in reading my post titled What Is Narration?

Post A Comment! Send to a Friend!

Comments

September 10, 2008 - Untitled Comment

Posted by Dana @ School For Us
I love how you came to do CM naturally. I, too, have had a problem with following someone else's methods. But, I do love so much of what CM teaches & HOW she teaches us to do it. But, I do it in my with my own style. And, I love how you mentioned that if you don't call it narration it takes some of the "pressure" off - well, those our my words, but I loved what you said!
Dana, www.alexml.blogspot.com
Permanent Link

September 14, 2008 - Narration

Posted by basketflat
Do you have your older children read assignments and do written assignments? At what age do you switch over to them reading their own assignments? Do you still cover the topic with the entire family?
Permanent Link

September 15, 2008 - Untitled Comment

Posted by amtell
I don't have a specific age when I switch to them reading their own assignments. Each year we do what works best at the time. If they still wanted assignments to be read to them at age 18, I would probably find a way do it.

I had planned to do Mystery of History Volume 3 with all the children this year, but I realized that the younger four really needed to go back and start with Volume 1. As much as I want to do MOH 3 with them, I realized that I do not have enough time to read two history curriculums. So my 10, 11, and 12 year old are reading history on their own and doing written narrations.

Last year I made up notebook pages for MOH 2 with guided questions for narration, but they said they prefered plain notebook pages with just a picture of the topic. So, that is what they are using this year.

The 12 year old and 11 year old are each doing their own science and are responsible for reading it on their own. My twelve year old is doing the General Science lapbook from Live and Learn because he needs more accountabilty and direction. My 11 year old is doing a nature notebook to go along with Zoology 3. It is mostly drawings, with a few notes to help him remeber key facts. He is a walking encyclopedia, especially when it comes to animal facts, and I didn't see any point in requiring long narrations which would just dampen his enthusiasm for the topic.

But, even though they are doing these things on their oown, they still "ease drop" on the younger kids lessons. And when they discuss their experiments or things they have learned, the younger kids want to know all about it. My kids are so nosy I think they are actually learning more about what their brothers and sisters are learning than they would be if they were studying it themselves. They can't stand missing out on anything. :-)

The most important thing to keep in mind is to do what God is leading you to do in your own family, because each family is different.
Permanent Link

September 15, 2008 - Untitled Comment

Posted by solidrock
Hi Melissa,
Just visiting. Have not been to your blog in forever. Love the explaination of narration in simple terms. We did the same science experiment. So much fun!!! The flea market looks like a great tradition! I know I could spend hours there! Say I love your dinner plates. They are the same as mine! Ours are 30 years old. I have had to replace a few pieces over the years but love the stuff. It however does not do well in new microwaves. Too much heat I am guessing. Causes cracks and crazing to the paint. We go the the pottery factory in Willamsburg yearly. ( they are rebuilding ). Has been a tradition for over 20 years in our family. I get replacement plates ect for less than half price. Well stop by sometime!
Permanent Link

September 17, 2008 - Untitled Comment

Posted by JamieLee
Good points. Thanks for sharing!
Permanent Link

September 18, 2008 - Untitled Comment

Posted by Della
What most drew me to Charlotte Mason, besides the fact that her ideas just made plain good sense was that it is so flexible. You can use all or one or two aspects. Because it is geared around education as a life, you can still feel free to live life while using it. It can so easily be tailored to fit a family's needs, I am just so thankful to have found it! Thanks for the great post!
Permanent Link

September 18, 2008 - Untitled Comment

Posted by Kayluray
Very well put. Thanks for sharing.
Permanent Link

September 21, 2008 - Untitled Comment

Posted by Homeschooling6
I have enjoyed your blog. I also wanted to day that next week I plan to start The Very Hungry Caterpillar lapbook with my younger kiddos. Looks fun. Hope to more like this.

I'm not very creative so finding this really helps me out.

Thanks & Blessings,
Linda<><
Permanent Link

September 21, 2008 - Hi..

Posted by gidget
Just popping in to say hi. I can't believe how long it's been since I've been here. I love how you described narration while teaching your lesson...I guess we've been doing narration that way for a while and didn't realize it. :-) ha ha
Permanent Link

Welcome!


Blog Links
Home
View my profile
Archives
Email Me
My Blog's RSS
Curriculum Reviews
Daily Life
Geography
History
Homeschooling
Lapbooking
Notebooking
Recipes
Science
Unit Studies

Homeschool Top Sites - Best Homeschool Sites on the Internet

hslaunch.com's list of top education blogs





Geography Unit Study
Japan Unit Study
China Unit Study
Mexico Unit Study
United States Unit Study
Native American Crafts and Activities
Slime Science
Old Testament Bible Lessons
Ancient History Lessons
Medieval History Lessons
Rock Unit Study
The Very Hungry Caterpillar

China Learning Kit


Notebooking Basics
Notebooking With Younger Children
Make Your Own Notebooking Pages

Lilliput Station notebook pages

Free & Affordable Notebooking Pages (& More!)

Notebooking Nook


Lapbooking Basics
What To Do With Lapbook Scraps
Sewing Lapbook



Lilliput Station Yahoo group


Locations of visitors to this page