Three's a Crowd

Mar. 4, 2009

A Bit Of Writing

I have decided that my kids need more writing practice in their lives so I started with a little intro into poetry, using a simple book my sister gave me years ago.  Chad and Alec did fine, even seemed to enjoy what we did.  Carmen, a.k.a. toadgirl, did not do well.  Anything new, she balks at and turns into a beast.  I hate that.  I'm patient and helpful but to no avail.  It's not pretty.

 

Anyway, Monday of this week, my sweet husband announced that he was going to the beach.  It was a beautiful day so we all stepped up the pace and finished our schoolwork earlier than normal.  Todd packed a lunch and we headed towards the ocean.  We were only gone about 1-1/2 hours, as Todd had to work that night, but we walked on two beaches and did some bird watching.  On one of the beaches, there were at least 3 dozen beached jellyfish.  Unbelieveable!  My younger two kids are still very interested in jellyfish and were fascinated, turning over the jellies with sticks for inspection.  Jellyfish creep me out but I keep my opinions to myself.  Todd and I saw a kestrel fly by and Chad saw several species of coastal birds.  The wind was fairly cold so we ate in the car while watching the water and headed back home around 3:00.  A terrific beach break.

 

So, yesterday, I told the kids were were going to write about our picnic at the beach.  They looked at me like I had asked them to walk barefoot on hot coals.  (I guess I don't do enough writing practice with them.)  Alec gave his typical "smart-alec" remarks but then asked if he could draw a picture to go with it.  Absolutely!  I said that sometimes a picture can inspire the words or sometimes the words inspire a picture.  He ended up drawing a very detailed, colorful picture of himself on the beach with the waves, birds, jellyfish, etc.  And his story was pretty good, with an illustrated title.  I was so proud of him!  In the life of a homeschool mom, where so many ideas and projects don't go as planned, it's such a joy when something goes well!

 

After hearing me praise Alec, Chad said to me, "Um, Mom, my story isn't going to be as involved as Alec's, o.k?"  Then I felt guilty.  I told Chad that he didn't need to do anything like Alec; he could write it anyway he wanted to.  I said that he and Alec are two completely different people and, of course, your stories would be different.  How does one praise one child without making the others feel like dirt?  My 13 year old son sometimes feels inferior to his younger brother in certain subjects and I always try to point out that he doesn't need to be like Alec.  Just be Chad.  And Chad's story WAS Chad's - written with his special brand of humor and intelligence.  I was very pleased and I think he was happy with it, too.  Another successfull ending!

 

And then there's toadgirl.  I did my best to help her write a few sentences about her time at the beach.  She balked.  I got frustrated.  I tried to be patient, kind, (and, no, I didn't call her toadgirl) but firm enough to let her know I wanted her to make an attempt.  Nothing but toadness.  Sorry, that's the best way to describe her attitude without using harsher words.  She always apologizes later for this behavior and I always forgive her but also ask her to remember the next day NOT to behave in this manner.  I guess it's the "phase" all my kids have gone through at this age.  She's definitely been the hardest to deal with.  Oh, Lord, I hope I can cope.  I just, you know, expect her to respond and act like her older brothers do but she's not them and she's only 8.  I need to find what works with her.  She is smart which works against her at times when she encounters something she doesn't understand.  She frustrates so quickly, even before I have a chance to explain something.  Then the attitude goes down the drain.  Then my patience wanes.  Prayer, that's what I need to do.  More of it.

 

Anyway, our little writing assignments have been fun and I think one a week is good for us.  Maybe I should ask Carmen to give me a writing assignment.  Hmmmm ... I may have something here! 

Post A Comment! Send to a Friend!

Comments

Mar. 5, 2009 - Dont' shoot me for this!

Posted by deedeeuk
But I'm going to take you back to your dear friend Charlotte Mason! LOL!

She is still young, so why not have her dictate the story for you to write? She could narrate the event to you or the story and you could tape it, video it or write it out for her. This will stimulate her imagination and her composition skills without frustrating her. They often can use much larger words than they can write and that is just frustrating to a small child!

My eldest is rather allergic to writing. Being a boy, and left handed doesn't help! I only require the minimum amount of written work in a week (spelling words and handwriting practice. All 'composition' type of writing is done orally.

Then last week he decided that he wanted to make a comic strip of something just for fun! Complete with words in the word bubbles!!!!! (can you see me turning carwheels?) He spelled things wrong, and he kept it short, but I didn't critisise because it was the first time he had VOLUNTARILY written anything in his life!!!

I'm sure he will come to writing when he finds a reason to write. It will just take time. BTW, he is 9 1/2. Hang in there! She is still young.
Permanent Link

Mar. 5, 2009 - Enjoyed

Posted by abbycamlars
I have really enjoyed reading your blog. Sherry
Permanent Link

Mar. 7, 2009 - Untitled Comment

Posted by 40winkzzz
One thing I have been reminded of a lot lately (esp thru IEW, which we're using for writing this year) is that kids often need us to jumpstart their brains when it comes to writing. "Write about this" is a frustrating mandate for most kids, even if it's something they have just done or something they enjoy and know a lot about. Sometimes my kids do better if I ask them questions &/or help them make a list of ideas before they write. "What is one thing you really enjoyed about our time at the beach?" "Can you tell me three things you noticed about the jellyfish?" Etc. Sometimes in talking about these things, something all of a sudden "clicks" and they brighten up and know what they want to write about. If not, you can resort to, "WHERE did we go? WHEN did we go? WHO went? WHY did we go? HOW did we get there? WHAT did we do there?"

Sometimes instead of asking my kids to write about something, I have just asked them to draw a picture of what we did or what we just learned about. (Again, if they say, "I don't know what to draw!" you might have to jumpstart with questions.) After they draw the picture, I ask them to tell me about the picture and I write down what they said. (Sometimes I ask questions here, too, if needed.) This is a sneaky way of getting them to "write" without realizing that they are writing! Or if the kids are up to it, you could simply ask them to write about their pictures. Looking at the pictures they drew helps them to communicate the experience or lesson in words. (Edit- in rereading your post, I see that you did mention this- "the picture can inspire the words".)

And btw, I have always considered illustration in & of itself to be a good language arts/writing exercise, b/c the kids are processing information and communicating it in their own way. This is true whether the child is illustrating a lit passage, a history or science lesson, scripture, or a personal experience, and it is true even if the child is not asked to verbally describe the picture. However, the latter *is* a beneficial writing "bonus" :-).

Your first commenter mentioned her son drawing a cartoon. After reading this idea on a blog, I have been having my kids draw "cartoons" (they don't have to be funny) about their history lessons. I used to have them narrate back to me, which constituted much of their writing, but since we are doing an official "writing program" this year, I'm not doing much narration with them. The history cartoons have provided a light-hearted yet effective way of having them communicate some of what they have learned. Just another thought for you to file away.




Edited by 40winkzzz on Mar. 7, 2009 at 12:56 PM
Permanent Link

Mar. 7, 2009 - Untitled Comment

Posted by 40winkzzz
Sorry; i just realized in seeing my comment above that it is almost as long as your post! AND, in going to copy it to the "blog comments" document (which I maintain in case I ever want to turn a comment I made on someone else's blog into a post on my own), I see that the last long comment I pasted there was also made on your blog. Hmm. Well, I'm not writing much on my own blog lately; may as well write on yours. :-)
Permanent Link

Mar. 8, 2009 - Untitled Comment

Posted by appleleaf
This is really fun to read. I could just picture the expressions on their faces when you dropped the bombshell. Maybe you'd better hang onto those written exercises for posterity. The personality really does come out in projects like that. I'm afraid we don't do all that much written work around here either, and I'd get the same reaction.
Blessings,
Paula
PS The excursion that started the written work sounded like lots of fun.
Permanent Link

About Me

Learning and living with my husband and three children on the northern-most tip of the Oregon Coast.

Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Email Me
My Blog's RSS
My Blogspot Blog

Friends

ByHisGraceInColorado
wardssward
DandelionSeeds
belindaletchford
WashingtonState
Lazycreek
AFJen88
kiwimumoffive
sherrydhoneycutt

Jimmie
appleleaf
jaminacema
Rebeca
deedeeuk
CTdittmar
danib
EEEEMommy
Stephanie10
annointed
Mama2Ways
CandyFoote
BattlementsofRubies
blueskiesandlemonade
CelticMom
AussieinAmerica
CountryMomof4
homeschoolmama

SeekingJESUSnTeachingKIDS
buffalorock
castlekids
MOMflippedisWOW
ComfyDenim
cathmom
debagain
EclecticallyOurs
jugglingpaynes
floridasnowflakes
crazybusy
jenn4him
40winkzzz
bethanyrae
babean
skdenfeld
moreofhim
Kinley
dixiefiddler
housefull
dixiecajuns
Amanda10Axelby
poohswife
luvs2bemom
bramasole
frenchbread
shermantribe
designed4me
earlyriser430
sheagang6
alikatts323
tjekj01
BIGPICKLE10
thystledown
Entry 26 of 244
Last Page | Next Page