a little perspective

"Thy word is a lamp unto my feet and a light unto my path."
Psalm 119:105


How history becomes mythology

posted Wednesday, May 31, 2006 :: 11:10 AM

We have been hard at work on the curriculum section of the new CCH website. One of the new pages recently added has to do with teaching mythology, as is necessary for a classical education, and explaining it as mythology from a biblical worldview. Here it is:


When your children ask where the fantastic legends of the Greeks came from, you can tell them that most legends have people and events in them that are exaggerated and impossible, but usually they begin with a grain of truth somewhere. For example, even though America is such a young country, we even have legends of Paul Bunyan with his big blue ox. The legends of Paul Bunyan illustrate in an exaggerated way the strength and skill of America’s early lumberjacks, and show how Americans must have been proud of their hard work and courage in doing such a difficult job.


While children need to learn classical mythology to be culturally literate in Western Civlization, the main point to communicate to them is that myths arose from a confused half-remembrance of true history. Bits of true history became mixed with false stories; the false stories came from willful rebellion at Babel which in time degenerated to foolish ignorance.


The Greeks, the descendents of Noah through Javan, forgot their true history and the true God, and all they had left of it was bits embedded in their mythology. In this way children will find it difficult to romanticize the Greek myths, and their appreciation for the accurate history contained in the Bible from the very beginning will be strengthened. (See Athena and Eve for a fascinating theory on the origin of the Greek pantheon and the patron goddess of Athens.)


To be continued ...


***
Update: continued in How history becomes mythology, part two

category: history
post a comment!

On Myth

posted Saturday, February 16, 2008 :: 6:24 AM :: by Anonymous
You might also want to note in your discussion of how myths develop that in societies that communicate history orally, it is impossible to accurately remember all the details that we do today. We can consult a written record. Oral cultures didn't have a written record to consult, so the story had to be structured in a way that preserved the essential truth of the matter (not the details of the matter) and then communicate that. Hence the myth preserves what we might call the moral of the story in a way that people could remember and repeat.

I don't think that really has anything to do with the Tower of Babel, but rather with the fact that most people around the world did not have the opportunity to learn to read and write (too busy working in the fields, herding livestock, etc) and thus communicated information over distance and through time in stories told orally in blocks of time less than four hours.

You can see that time block in the individual stories inside longer myths...see the 1001 Nights for instance.

When folks began writing stories down, their form became fixed. Subsequent editors had the opportunity to compile various forms and rationalize the story either by embellishing and explaining certain parts in greater detail or cutting out confusing parts and now we have the opportunity to argue about how one is the "true" story and other editions of it were "broken" or confused. In fact, we often have the same story (same heart) encapsulated in a different rememberable and tellable shell. I think this is less decadent and degenerative and more purposeful and natural on the the part of the oral tellers than you suggest.
permanent link :: ::

On Myth

posted Saturday, February 16, 2008 :: 6:25 AM :: by Anonymous
You might also want to note in your discussion of how myths develop that in societies that communicate history orally, it is impossible to accurately remember all the details that we do today. We can consult a written record. Oral cultures didn't have a written record to consult, so the story had to be structured in a way that preserved the essential truth of the matter (not the details of the matter) and then communicate that. Hence the myth preserves what we might call the moral of the story in a way that people could remember and repeat.

I don't think that really has anything to do with the Tower of Babel, but rather with the fact that most people around the world did not have the opportunity to learn to read and write (too busy working in the fields, herding livestock, etc) and thus communicated information over distance and through time in stories told orally in blocks of time less than four hours.

You can see that time block in the individual stories inside longer myths...see the 1001 Nights for instance.

When folks began writing stories down, their form became fixed. Subsequent editors had the opportunity to compile various forms and rationalize the story either by embellishing and explaining certain parts in greater detail or cutting out confusing parts and now we have the opportunity to argue about how one is the "true" story and other editions of it were "broken" or confused. In fact, we often have the same story (same heart) encapsulated in a different rememberable and tellable shell. I think this is less decadent and degenerative and more purposeful and natural on the the part of the oral tellers than you suggest.
permanent link :: ::

<- last page :: next page ->

welcome

Visit with Christine Miller awhile and let's share our thoughts on homeschooling, education, and life.
:: home :: rss site feed
:: archives :: email me

next biblical feast day

8th biblical month new moon
:: projected ::
sunset, mon oct 19 2009
(feast days run from sunset to sunset)
this first day is not/b> a sabbath
significance of the new moon
celebrating the new moon








remember the victims of islamic terrorism


Pray for the peace of Jerusalem
:: Why I support Israel
:: Why my church supports Israel
:: Bridges for Peace
:: Christian Action for Israel
:: Christian Friends of Israel
:: Christians United for Israel
:: Int'l Christian Embassy Jerusalem
:: Messianic Israel Alliance
United States :: 09/11
:: the religion of peace
:: american congress for truth

recent posts

:: Coming out of Babylon
:: Fall feasts of the Lord
:: Today is the national muslim day of prayer
:: Spankings lower IQs?
:: "All are equal in his sight"
:: Brits tighten screws on homeschooling
:: Urgent call to prayer
:: Prayer for Israel

popular posts

:: The righteousness that is of faith
:: Safeguard your investment in your children
:: The Babylon connection
:: Revelation series
:: How history becomes mythology
:: On faults, logs, and reconciliation
:: Advice for a new homeschooler
:: Beating homeschool burnout
:: There is too much, let me sum up
:: A rabbit trail
:: Why history?
:: When tragedy strikes
:: The pressure of perfection
:: Family law
:: The prayer of Jesus
:: Have no other gods before Me

categories

:: Adventures in grandparenting
:: America the beautiful
:: Applied word
:: Blogkeeping
:: Books
:: Christianity
:: Education
:: Eyes on the fig tree
:: Family and society
:: Gratia
:: History
:: Homeschooling
:: Humanitas
:: Philosophy
:: Poetry
:: Real life
:: Science
:: Theology
:: The rhetoric stage
:: Website news
:: Why we homeschool
:: Work in progress

christine's blogs & sites

:: a little perspective
:: christine's kitchen
:: Classical Christian Homeschooling
:: Nothing New Press
:: this side of heaven

christine's books


"The Story of the Romans provides an introductory context for the culture and ideas so foundational to the development of Western thought.�
Anne Weiland :: The Old Schoolhouse Magazine
:: read a chapter from this book
:: more books

"For new and veteran homeschool families alike, this extensive new release from the editors of The Old Schoolhouse Magazine serves as a homeschool convention in a book. It details today's most viable education models, helping parents formulate an educational game plan and choose teaching methodologies. There are more than twenty contributors." Including Christine Miller, who wrote a chapter on Classical Education.

christine's reading








I am researching the holy days which were instituted by God as a celebration of the Messiah, instead of celebrating the holy days which were instituted by man to honor nature in place of nature's God.
:: Israel's Feast - Wooten
:: Annals - Ussher

christine's listening to







This is a new CD, and it has proven to be the most beautiful, reverent worship music we own yet. Tom Ewing is the gifted worship pastor at Resurrection Fellowship in Loveland, Colorado.
:: We Bring Our Crowns
:: Enter the Worship Circle

daily bread

Look up a word or passage in the Bible



BibleGateway.com
:: Bible study tools
:: Daily audio bible
:: Daily devotionals
:: ESV daily devotions
:: NET Bible
:: A.W. Tozer's Insight for Leaders
:: John Stocker's daily podcast
:: Wellsprings of Torah

blogging

:: 10 Key Ingredients of a Great Blog
:: Blogging 101
:: How to Start a Blog
:: Homeschool Blogger
:: Homestead Blogger
:: Blog Carnival Index
:: Bloglet subscriptions
:: Blogrolling
:: Legal Guide for Bloggers
:: Sitemeter
:: Truth Laid Bear Ecosystem
:: Wordpress.com

carnivals & communities

:: Biblical Studies Carnival
:: Blogdom of God
:: Carnival of Beauty
:: Carnival of Education
:: Carnival of Homeschooling
:: Carnival of the Recipes
:: Christian Carnival
:: Darwin is Dead Carnival
:: Evangelical Aggregator
:: Festival of Frugality
:: History Carnival
:: Philosopher's Carnival
:: Pro Life Blogs
:: Theology Blogs

citizenship

:: Acton Institute
:: CitizenLink.org
:: Founders' Constitution
:: Liberty Library
:: Pro Life Blogs
:: Pro Life Pulse
:: The Unalienable Right
:: more coming ...

comedy

:: Dave Barry
:: Cox & Forkum
:: Day by Day
:: Michael Ramirez
:: Scrappleface
:: Townhall Funnies

domestic arts

:: Girl Talk
:: A Gracious Home
:: Holy Experience
:: The Porch Light
:: more coming ...

education

:: 1000 Good Books List
:: 100 Great Books List
:: Bede's Library
:: GCC: Vision & Values
:: Rhetorical Response
:: Underground Grammarian
:: more coming ...

evangelism

:: Advancing Native Missions
:: Answers in Genesis
:: Asian Access
:: Bible League
:: Book of Hope
:: Compassion International
:: Escape from Darkness
:: Gospel for Asia
:: Latin America Mission
:: Mission Aviation Fellowship
:: Overseas Missionary Fellowship
:: Persecution Project
:: Reaching Unreached Nations
:: SAT-7
:: Wycliffe Bible Translators

humanities

:: Art Renewal Center
:: Albert Bierstadt
:: William Adolphe Bouguereau
:: William Morris
:: Norman Rockwell
:: Charles Wysocki
:: more coming ...

local links - colorado

:: Colorado Bloggers
:: Colorado for Equal Rights
:: Colorado Freedom Report
:: John Fielder's Colorado
:: Homeschool Nation: Colorado
:: Homeschooling in Colorado
:: Rocky Mountain Blog Alliance
:: Rocky Mountain News
:: State of Colorado
:: more coming ...

local links - florida

:: more coming ...

media

:: Christian Spotlight
:: Movie Guide
:: Movie Ministry
:: Preview Online
:: Good Eats
:: Stargate Atlantis

music

:: 2nd Chapter of Acts
:: Desperation Band
:: Jeff Deyo
:: Don Francisco
:: Enter the Worship Circle
:: Iona
:: Dennis Jernigan
:: Phil Keaggy
:: Terry Kelley Band
:: Larry Norman
:: Petra
:: John Michael Talbot

news

:: Christian Post
:: Drudge Report
:: Fox News
:: Front Page Magazine
:: Jerusalem Post
:: Life Site News
:: Middle East News and Analysis
:: Mission Network News
:: NewsMax.com
:: One News Now
:: Pajamas Media
:: Townhall.com
:: Washington Times
:: World Magazine
:: World Net Daily
:: World Watch Daily

opinion

:: Mike S. Adams
:: Atlas Shrugs
:: Michael Barone
:: Glenn Beck
:: Brussels Journal
:: Ann Coulter
:: Crunchy Cons
:: Free Republic
:: Brigitte Gabriel
:: Mark Levin
:: Little Green Footballs
:: Rush Limbaugh
:: Michelle Malkin
:: National Review Online
:: Benjamin Netanyahu
:: Peggy Noonan
:: Chuck Norris
:: Mark Steyn

origins

:: Ancient Days
:: Answers in Genesis
:: Cosmic Fingerprints
:: Creation Ministries International
:: Creation vs. evolution
:: Creation/ evolution headlines
:: Creation science books online
:: Creationism.org
:: CreationWiki
:: Darwinian fundamentalism
:: Institute for Creation Research

:: True Origin Archive
:: Uncommon Descent
:: more coming ...

philosophy

:: more coming ...

religion

:: Albert Mohler
:: Around the World - Ken Ham
:: Bede's Journal
:: Best of the God Blogs
:: Biblical Horizons
:: Breakpoint with Chuck Colson
:: ChurchThink
:: Contratimes
:: Every Thought Captive
:: Girl Talk
:: Internet Monk
:: JackLewis.net
:: Mere Comments
:: Middlebrow
:: Roots by the River
:: Slice of Laodicea
:: Smart Christian
:: Together for the Gospel
:: more coming ...

theology

:: A Christian ThinkTank
:: Apologetics Classics Library
:: Bereans Online
:: Biblical contradictions debunked
:: C. J. Mahaney
:: First Fruits of Zion
:: Get Answers
:: Grafted In an On the Journey
:: J. C. Ryle
:: Jews and Joes
:: John MacArthur
:: Messianic Jewish Musings
:: Messianics for Torah
:: Restoration of Torah
:: Wildbranch Ministry
:: more coming ...



stats


Site Meter

My amazon.com wishlist