The Gatekeeper's Pen
Nov. 10, 2008
Some Thoughts on Fantasy, Part 1

As you all know, my favorite genre of literature is fantasy. I've loved fantasy stories ever since I can remember, and most of the stories I've made up (and both of the ones I've written down) are also fantasy. Apparently I'm not alone in this. It seems like no matter what bookstore I walk into, there's a new installment of some fantasy series on the best-seller shelf. Part of the reason probably has to do with the Harry Potter craze, and the fact that every children's author in America is trying to imitate it, but I think a lot of people simply find fantasy appealing.

Being one of those people, I've decided to devote a short series of posts to my favorite genre. To start things off, I'm going to describe what I see as the two main catagories of fantasy books. Later I'll look at what attracts people to fantasy, the purpose of fantasy, and maybe a few suggestions on how to write fantasy.

Fantasy is kind of a broad term. Because most fantasy literature involves some kind of magical world, the possibilities for what you can do with that world are endless. That's one of the things I like about fantasy. However, in my mind, most of the fantasy books published nowadays fit into one of two catagories: the modern fairy-tale and the fantasy epic.

1) The modern fairy-tale. This catagory is usually written for children, and it takes place more or less in our world. The story-line basically goes like this: a couple of ordinary children (usually a girl and a boy) discover a magical secret. Oftentimes it's a door into another world, but sometimes it's a magic creature or object from our world, hinting that planet Earth is not as ordinary and predictable as it might seem. The children then have a series of adventures, during which one or both of them usually receives a gift which will help them accomplish some mission in the new world.

Books in this catagory are characterized by magic and fairy-tale type creatures. They always involve some sort of battle against evil, but they're usually pretty light-hearted and kid-friendly. The best example of this kind of book is The Chronicles of Narnia, of course, but there are a few good modern examples as well. 100 Cupboards is one of them.

2) The fantasy epic. This catagory is probably the most popular and the least well-done. It's targeted more towards adults and teens, and it takes place entirely in the fantasy world. The basic story line is very simple, and goes like this: a dark power rises and tries to take over an imaginary world. The forces of good fight back, and there are several epic battles, but an unlikely hero ultimately saves the day. This type of book is usually very detailed, full of creatures, countries, cultures, and often even languages invented by the author.

The only problem with this catagory is that, to my knowledge, there's only one author that ever did it right. J.R.R. Tolkien invented the fantasy epic, and he also set the standard for it. Unfortunately he set the standard so high that no one has been able to reach it since. He did everything right, so there was nothing left for future authors to do. Every modern attempt at writing a fantasy epic just sounds like a copy of The Lord of the Rings. A prime example of this is the Inheritance trilogy, which includes almost a word-for-word quote from The Fellowship of the Ring. The fantasy epic is, in theory, a great genre, but the standard is just too high. So, unless you consider yourself a genius of Tolkien's caliber, don't attempt to write one.

I'm not saying that every fantasy book ever written fits into these catagories. There's the traditional fairy tale, of course - we all know what that's like - and the anti-fairytale, which has become pretty popular in the last decade or so with movies like Shrek and books like Ella Enchanted. But there aren't as many of those books, so I didn't think they needed a catagory of their own. There's also the wizard's tale, which was started (I think) by Harry Potter and is a little more common. I didn't include that for two reasons: one, I've never read a book in that catagory, and two, it seems to have the same problem as the fantasy epic. Everyone is just copying J.K. Rowling.

And then there's sci-fi fantasy, which, in my opinion, is a different genre altogether. That's where things can get really weird (and cool). But that's another post.


Comments

Nov. 11, 2008 - Untitled Comment

Posted by The Gradually Sanctified

I wonder if any of us will ever live to see another genius write a fantasy epic that can equal or (even more incredible) surpass J.R.R. Tolkien's works. He (or she) would have to get really good at breaking the norm, because if he/she tried to follow Tolkien's formula he would end up just copying him all over again. Yeah... maybe it will never happen.

Permanent Link


Nov. 14, 2008 - nice!

Posted by Anonymous

Good Post GK!!
Do you think it is possible to wright a great fantasy epic if he/she has not read Lord of the Rings, and therefore can not copy it?

Permanent Link


Nov. 14, 2008 - Untitled Comment

Posted by thegatekeeper

You can try. :)

Permanent Link


Nov. 17, 2008 - Wow

Posted by horsewings

Oh wow! That was a great post! You obviously know a lot about fantsy writings, and you catogorized them well. I, too, am a fantasy lover and (attempting) to be an author of fantsy. I love your blog and I think it's a great idea to have Authors of the Month. I would not mind being friends with you, and I think I might add you to my friends list.

Permanent Link


A place to read and comment about books, writing, and things like that

Recent Posts

The Winners!
Beginnings
The Problem of Evil (for readers and writers)
Read-Alouds
What Is a Hero?

Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Email Me
My Blog's RSS

CLICK HERE TO GET YOUR FREE BAND


180x90_Prayer-Bands-v2

Friends

BrielleCostumes
grackoid
Lucy
intothewardrobe
wallyaqh
SolidFaith
InNarnia
horsewings
Erulisse
LadyMaie

Widget_logo

Entry 18 of 58
Last Page | Next Page