Principled Discovery

May. 13, 2006

Turn On, Tune In, Tune Out

Posted in education
At one time researchers from every political and religious persuasion warned against television for young children. Here are links to two different research studies outlining the negative effects of television on young children. We are continually being urged by experts to at least limit television viewing by children. Yet the market for infant television and video games is exploding. It is a demand driven market, and I cannot help but wonder, "What are these parents thinking?"

In her post, High Tech Parenting, Spunky describes BabyTV, the first television dedicated solely to babies and their parents. As if the hours on Nickelodeon and PBS did not provide enough television aimed specifically at the pre-talking set.

There is a television in just about every classroom and every daycare. As parents, we see the deadening effect that an hour in front of the television does to a child. Yet it is continually promoted in classrooms as part of integrating technology in the classroom and viewed as an opportunity to make more meaningful connections between the curriculum and the child. Cable in the Classroom provides over 500 hours of television to schools across the nation, working in partnership with cable companies to improve our nation's media literacy. Free lesson plans are available that incorporate popular television programs at every grade level.

The greatest negative effects on reading skills were recorded in children watching three or more hours of television per day. Does this include time spent in edutainment settings in the classroom? Or the curriculum DVD's offered by some homeschooling publishers?

Althoug in its infancy, cell phone television is proving profitable in the 0-3 market as well. According to Time to Flip "up" the Telly, a Newsday.com article,
Parents report they can quiet squirming tykes instantly in long lines and waiting rooms by flipping "Sesame Street" clips or Discovery Kids streams into their line of sight.
Anything but interact with them.

Post A Comment! Send to a Friend!

Comments

May. 14, 2006 - Oh My............

Posted by creativehsmom
TV programming for babies! Hubby and I were just discussing the stupidity of the concept yesterday........sigh...............but anyway............

Permanent Link

May. 14, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by hugs4Him
We don't watch TV; dh does, but I never put it on for the kids. My one son liked Little House now & then, but I dislike the shows & am steering him toward the books! The books of anything are always better.
Anyway, thanks for your always informative posts & Happy Mother's Day Dana!
Permanent Link

May. 15, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by leslienoelani
"It is a demand driven market, and I cannot help but wonder, "What are these parents thinking?""

I think they're convincing themselves that "It's not *that* bad, extremists are just over-reacting," or else they deceive themselves about how much time their children are spending with electronic media. I hear mothers say, "my kids don't spend much time watching TV," but then when they list the shows their kids are hooked on, it's a couple hours or more a day, plus whatever shows they watch in the evenings.

I think every parent should read Endangered Minds as a prerequisite to raising children.
Permanent Link

May. 15, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by gottsegnet
Excellent point. Many parents compare their children's viewing habits to other children. I was shocked at statistics indicating that preschoolers may be watching up to 60 hours per week. If you know that is the norm, than allowing your toddler to watch three hours a day seems like, "not that much." And many think that because they are screening the viewing, they are escaping the negative effects. But the research shows that the mere act of television viewing has harmful effects on the development of children, not just the questionable content.

In excess, Blue's Clues, Bob the Builder, Thomas the Tank Engine and other "harmless" shows will still lead to attention problems, a disconnect with reality, poor vision, possible hearing difficulties, lowered reasoning skills and the other problems that have come out in recent studies.
Permanent Link

May. 18, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by creativehsmom
Oh Dana, this is a "superb" post! I have to bookmark this and show it to others or maybe do a track back from my blog. I was trying to explain something similar on the debate blog but you've summed it all up right here!
Cathy :o)
Permanent Link

May. 19, 2006 - <i>Untitled Comment</i>

Posted by
Thank you, Cathy! Not too long ago, there was some study that connected Alar to cancer. Mothers across the US threw out their apples and poured apple juice down the drain. It did not take that long to get Alar off the market. Now we have thousands of pages of research about the harmful effects of television, including physical problems, emotional problems, academic problems and social problems. And we continue to see an increase in demand for televisions and for programming aimed at young children. Parents respond with, "Well, I think television can be good if..." but no research supports that.

I have some other thoughts, but I've already talked about television three times this week, so I might wait until next week : )

Edited by gottsegnet on May. 19, 2006 at 6:27 AM
Permanent Link

About Me

"Democracy and socialism have nothing in common but one word, equality. But notice the difference: while democracy seeks equality in liberty, socialism seeks equality in restraint and servitude."--Alexis de Toqueville

Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Email Me
My Blog's RSS

Friends

UndertheSky
TOSPUBLISHER
LovingHim4Ever
ByHisGraceInColorado
spunkyhomeschool

JillNovak
MamaBugs
Kellyque777
creativehsmom
schooldaze
belindaletchford
LisaQuing
redmom
meandmyhouse
GalacticBlogger
thehsmomof2
Titus2woman
Hutcheson
Manicmondaymomma
dswescott

nebraska
Cre8iveMom
lifeandtimesofanothermom
principledlearner
Raquel
NewHarvest
Michaela
rainbowdash

Honeybee
Dalaimama
SingingHisStory
loughman98
Lazycreek
iluvtheland
JennLovesJesus
mistresninos
Janne
Amber
leslienoelani
chickadee


lovetolearnmom
writmm

AmoScribo

TRINITYPREPSCHOOL
WalkInFaith
danib
telmar

dinomomm
HSmom0f4

Jocelyndixon
SuperAngel
RugbyHS
homeschoolingmommaof4

AussieinAmerica
home4mariah
littleskipper
Keri
onecrazymom
domesticangel
Entry 182 of 419
Last Page | Next Page