Principled Discovery

Feb. 15, 2006

Motivation

Posted in motivation
I stumbled across an interesting entry over on Edwahoo's blog that brought up an issue worth consideration.  Here I offer only further thought and reflection, no solutions.

The American Heritage Dictionary's definition of motivation is essentially worthless.  Who can make anything out of this:

mo·ti·va·tion Pronunciation (mt-vshn)
n.
1.
a. The act or process of motivating.
b. The state of being motivated.
2. Something that motivates; an inducement or incentive.

I strongly dislike definitions which presuppose an understanding of the word you are looking up.

Obviously, there is a root idea of motion.  So my definition, which is as good as anything I could find, shall be:  that which sets something in motion, or compels to action.

I bring this up because motivation is such a tremendous issue in society today.  Motivational speakers make big bucks speaking in business, schools, clubs and even homeschool groups.  Many of the blogs I read mention motivation (or lack thereof) as a significant factor in their home education.  Parents seem to be craving knowledge on how to motivate their children to do just about anything.  In fact, a simple google search brings over 2 million websites (200,000 more than googling motivational speakers).

I would be quick to argue that it is good for students to be motivated.  But I also believe great care must be taken in our attempts to motivate them.  All of us should act with a driving force, a sense of purpose, a set of values which compels us to action.  But from whence do you derive your motivation?

Intrinsic motivation comes from within.  It is your heart, your conscious, your will acting to effect your environment.  It is acting out of conviction and your personal judgment of the right course of action in a given situation.  Often, however, our primary motivation is extrinsic, or external.  We set rulers over ourselves.  We choose our course of action based on what others will think or the rewards/punishments that we imagine will result.  Ironically, we seem to serve as our own extrinsic motivator as we set up our own rewards to give ourselves when we do what we think we should be doing.

Is this because we truly are what we eat?  Are we merely a product of our environment?  If we are successful in altering the external environment of an individual, will we be able to truly produce a better internal character in the individual?  This is the main tenet of socialism...alter the environment and we can shape the individual.

Or is it because we, too, are indoctrinated somewhat into this system? 

How can we go about appealing to the internal aspects of our children?  How can we inspire them so that they form convictions which they will act on, despite the environmental influences going on around them. 

Our sermon on Sunday related a story that really affected me.  A man was beaten nearly to death in Iraq.  His aggressors demanded he renounce his faith.  He refused and the beatings worsened until he was finally left for dead.  Friends found him, and luckily he survived.  After recovering, he praised God.  Not for sparing him and aiding in his recovery, but for giving him the strength to not deny his Lord in the face of death.

He was not able to confess Christ in this moment because of any perceived benefit or fear of punishment.  He was motivated by a strong conviction that compelled him to speak the truth, despite the circumstances. 

, , , ,




• Post A Comment! • Send to a Friend!

Comments

Feb. 16, 2006 - Thursday Thirteen

Posted by loughman98
Ok, i think i finally got the thursdya thirteen thing figured out! yippee!! lol
• Permanent Link

Feb. 16, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by spunkyhomeschool
I have a half done post on this myself. I have been working on it for a little while. Then I saw Edwahoo's and another teachers and I am reeeditting it. I like your thoughts. Well said,
• Permanent Link

Feb. 16, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by gottsegnet
I'll look forward to reading your thoughts, as well. I think I may be coming back to this a bit later. It is actually rather foundational to why we chose to homeschool and to the curriculum choices we have made.
• Permanent Link

Feb. 16, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by TOSPUBLISHER
I am motivated to buy a goat. Maybe can it, too. Anyway, you are very smart; I love your blog.
• Permanent Link

Feb. 16, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by TOSPUBLISHER
And no, but seriously, that was a very cool entry. I can't imagine being in that situation (beaten half to death). I only hope I would never deny my Lord. Scary to wonder about.

-gena :-)
• Permanent Link

Feb. 16, 2006 - Goats

Posted by gottsegnet
Good luck on the goat...when it has kids, are you going to give them away? I am almost to the point of crossing my fingers on a property with five acres. Not quite JenIg's Curry Farms, but five acres of Hanley Haven will do for me. I want goats because I want goats. I'll figure out what on earth you do with the little buggers once I get them.

I hear they are motivated to eat. They can mow my grass for me since I don't intend on pushing our mower that far.
• Permanent Link

Feb. 18, 2006 - teaching motivation

Posted by danib
Lots to ponder here ...

The problem I seem to face almost daily is that, in trying to teach her the values and morals necessary to motivate her in the future, I find that she is utterly unmotivated to learn even this much. Call her Dobson's "strong-willed child" (like her mother), she refuses to learn what she doesn't want to learn.

Is this a motivation in itself -- say, a self-guided learning style? While I'm glad she wants to learn certain things, other things are foundational to those lessons, and she is bound to fail. With this one, extremes of emotions cause her to swing wildly from confidence and determination to absolute despair -- letting her fail so miserably has actually led to instances of fear at approaching new things in general.

Feels like a roundabout ... How to motivate to learn those things which will ultimately motivate on their own? Any thoughts?

Dani
• Permanent Link

Feb. 18, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by gottsegnet
Thank you for your thoughts! If I had the answers, I could make thousands as a motivational speaker and author. Later, I plan to actually flesh this out a bit into something of a theory of my very own...with the hope of seeing its fruition in my children. But I think, too, at some point we have to realize that they are individuals. There are many things that we can do to set them on the right path or even the wrong one, but in the end, the choices they make are their own.
I would like my daughter to learn to own her decisions....the good and the bad. Right now, everything seems to be her brother's fault, or a misunderstanding or forgetfulness. Or even, "Mom, I'm only seven." But some day, with work, I hope she will realize that her actions are hers alone, regardless of the environmental pressures.

• Permanent Link

About Me

"Democracy and socialism have nothing in common but one word, equality. But notice the difference: while democracy seeks equality in liberty, socialism seeks equality in restraint and servitude."--Alexis de Toqueville

Links

• Home
• View my profile
• Archives
• Email Me
• My Blog's RSS

Friends

• UndertheSky
• TOSPUBLISHER
• LovingHim4Ever
• ByHisGraceInColorado
• spunkyhomeschool
•
• JillNovak
• MamaBugs
• Kellyque777
• creativehsmom
• schooldaze
• belindaletchford
• LisaQuing
• redmom
• meandmyhouse
• GalacticBlogger
• thehsmomof2
• Titus2woman
• Hutcheson
• Manicmondaymomma
• dswescott
•
• nebraska
• Cre8iveMom
• lifeandtimesofanothermom
• principledlearner
• Raquel
• NewHarvest
• Michaela
• rainbowdash
•
• Honeybee
• Dalaimama
• SingingHisStory
• loughman98
• Lazycreek
• iluvtheland
• JennLovesJesus
• mistresninos
• Janne
• Amber
• leslienoelani
• chickadee
•
•
• lovetolearnmom
• writmm
•
• AmoScribo
•
• TRINITYPREPSCHOOL
• WalkInFaith
• danib
• telmar
•
• dinomomm
• HSmom0f4
•
• Jocelyndixon
• SuperAngel
• RugbyHS
• homeschoolingmommaof4
•
• AussieinAmerica
• home4mariah
• littleskipper
• Keri
• onecrazymom
• domesticangel
Entry 260 of 419
Last Page | Next Page