Our Homeschooling Expedition

Apr. 25, 2007

An Interesting Article Refuted

Posted in Mommas Opinions
 

I come across several articles I think to myself I should blog about that article.  Then I don’t because I think I don’t want to bore people with my opinions.  Well guess what!  I’m going to start boring you once a week.  And just so you know I’m an ultra conservative and very opinionated.  I’m not out to offend anybody I just thought I’d share my views on things.  I also love a good clean debate so don’t be afraid to post an opposite view point from mine.  I promise I will not attack you personally; I won’t degrade or name call either.  I would appreciate if you would follow the same and please link any related info.  Though I still want to keep the focus of this blog to homeschooling and our life but once a week I’m going to get opinionated.    Now here is my first entry.

 

I came across this article titled “The Downside to Homeschooling” and about laughed because I think the same list can be used as reasons to homeschool.  Here I’ll break it down like she did.

 

Social Interaction

 

First let’s look at the definition of the word social.  There are several but the one I think that relates best is: tending to form cooperative and interdependent relationships with one’s kind.    It doesn’t say only with one’s kind and age, it says with one’s kind.  One’s kind is what we refer to as our society.  The definition of society is:  a community, nation, or broad grouping of people having common traditions,institutions, and collective activities and interests.  See even in this definition it doesn’t say anything about age it says a broad grouping.  Therefore does it not make sense for our children to be socialized in an atmosphere that truly prepares them for society?  Homeschooling is a prime environment for this.  Homeschooled kids get to interact with a wide range of people on a daily bases.  As for the teamwork that is taught through sports in public school, homeschool kids learn teamwork not only through sports but through daily living and educating.  I know my children learn teamwork by working on projects together and when we do work on the house as a family.  They also participate in various sports and clubs.  Teamwork is not only taught through sports but through cooperation in completing a task or project.  Teamwork is not only needed in physical activities but also in mental work.

 

Lessons

 

This one is laughable.  Are you telling me that children who go to public school don’t ever get frustrated or that the teachers never do?  Please.  Getting frustrated is part of life it is how we deal with these frustrations that matters.  Homeschool teachers are very supportive of each other if we are feeling frustrated or unsure about something we just reach out to another homeschool teacher.  Sometimes just talking it out will help and sometimes they’ve been there done that and can give you pointers or a different perspective.  And quite frankly I think if nice that I’m there to help my child deal with his frustration at his schoolwork and help him work through it.  I will also admit that I’m not excellent in every subject but I will also tell my child I don’t know let’s go find out.  If there is some subject that our child is really struggling with homeschool teachers are usually the first to ask for help, search for a different approach, or find a solution because we want them to succeed. 

 

I remember when I was in high school I was having a problem with geometry so I asked the teacher for help.  Her reply was read the book.  I said I read the book and I still don’t get it.  She just replied read the book again and went back to reading her book.  I also had another teacher that taught business law and he would just write the notes on the board, the pages to read, and the questions to answer.  When the bell rang he'd say do this and point to the board.  That was the extent of his teaching.  How is that not frustrating to a child.  I’m not saying all teachers are that way but I know enough of them to keep my kids home.  I believe homeschool teachers will go that extra mile to help because it is our children.

 

Dances

 

I’m sorry to say but I think the public school atmosphere causes public school kids to value these dances.  I never went to any and honestly I didn’t feel slighted then or now.  Our church did hold lots of teen activities that I participated in and they were a lot of fun.  I remember listening to kids talk about the dances it was a well known fact that immoral behavior was expected at these events.  I think that is enough to make my children feel deprived from partaking in these events.  Enough said.

 

Graduation

 

Now granted not every homeschool kid partakes in a graduation ceremony but neither does every public school kid.  There are many options for graduation.  There are events sponsored by homeschool groups.  You can order a graduation certificate off the internet and throw a graduation for your child yourself.  There is no reason for a child to be deprived of a graduation if they want one.  Granted it won’t have 300 or more kids but it will definitely be an event that they remember forever.  It will be an event where they know everybody and everyone is thrilled for them.

 

So in my opinion the reasons given in the mentioned article are shaky at best and can easily be looked at from a different perspective. 

 

 

Post A Comment! Send to a Friend!

Comments

Apr. 26, 2007 - Response

Posted by Anonymous
Unfortunetly, after reading this article about the "Downside to Homeschooling", the only thought that came across my mind was how very shallow this writers knowledge of homeschooling was.

I would not trade my child's many year's of "rich" schooling experience at home for all the invites to their friends graduation parties. We're talking about one night where the possibilities of "not so good things" could end up happening at that party, are very likely. There are better options.
Permanent Link

Jun. 24, 2007 - Love your bloggin

Posted by geeterbug5
I love your blogs they are interesting and informative...LoveIt!!!
Okay I read this article as well and I read the one she posted on the pros and I feel this girl, woman whatever ,has no understanding. Most of her article was based on going somewhere & participating in afterschool dances she has no clue either way on the education side of the whole matter.
On the pro side ,she got it right. We can take all the time we need to help our child learn and know the material without having to FAKE IT.
Obviously to report on something you should educate yourself on the issue.
Permanent Link

About Me

We are a homeschooling family of 6. Come join us as we travel along life's road.



Our Happenings

My Ramblings
The Daily Adventures of Us
Life with Toddlers
What The Kids Are Up To
What Momma is up to
Our Health Goals
Mommas Opinions


This and That

2008 Book Challenge


Bible

Bible for Kids
The Ten Commandments
Lessons on Love
Lessons from Genesis
Parables
Stories


Electives

Art
Computer
Foreign Language
Music
Physical Education
Typing
Virtual Field Trips




Subscribe to Our Homeschooling Expedition by Email

Google Groups
Homeschooling on a Budget
Visit this group



Notebooking and Lapbooking

Lapbooking and Notebooking
Notebooking Pages
Lapbook Samples


Extras

Online Reference Materials
School Forms
Webquest
Worksheet Generators
Character Education
Free Unit Studies




Frugal Living

Garage Sales
Tip of The Week

Health

The 5 Senses
Teeth
The Food Pyramid




Holidays

Christmas
Columbus Day
Halloween
Thanksgiving
Valentine Day
Easter
Veterans Day
Martin Luther King Day

Homeschooling

Free Curriculum
Free Things
Homeschooling Tips




Language Arts

Adjectives and Adverbs
Conjunctions
Dictionary Skills
Handwriting
Writing
Noun
Pronouns
Reading
Sentence Fragments and Runons
Spelling
Subjects and Predicates
Synonyms Antonyms Homonyms
Verbs


Math

Addition and Subtraction
Algebra
Charts and Graphs
Decimals
Fractions
Math
Multiplication and Division
Number Words
Place Values
Roman Numerals
Rounding
Story Problems
Time

Organization

Home
Homeschool
Menu Plan Monday


Preschool

ABC
Activities
Colors
Cut and Paste
Color by Numbers
Matching
PreWriting Skills
Shapes
Apples Unit
Balloons Unit
Bubbles Unit
Circus Unit
Ducks Unit
Elephants Unit
Frogs Unit
Games Unit
Hats Unit
Ice Cream Unit
Jungle Unit
Ketchup Unit


Science

Amphibians
Animal Classification
Annelids
Backyard Bugs
Birds
Chemistry
Echnioderms
Electricity
Fish
General Science Links
Mammals
Mollusk
Plants Unit
Protozoa
Reptiles
Scientific Method
Simple Machines
Water
Weather




Social Studies

American Revolution
Ancient Egypt
Ancient Rome
Civil War
General History Links
Geography
Medieval Times
My Community
Native Americans
The Holocaust
The 50 States



My Other Blogs

Mommaof4's Weblog
Homeschooling on a Budget
Joann's Lapbook Lessons



My 2008 Booklist

Pied Piper
A Day of Pleasure
Alice Adventures in Wonderland
The Hobbit
Treasure Island
The Story of My Life
The Scarlet Letter
Jane Eyre
Boxers to Bandits
Fall on Your Knees
The Champdoce Mystery
All Creatures Great and Small
Wish You Well
To The Lighthouse
Ben Hur
Bannertail the Story of a Gray Squirrel
Fearlessly Feminine
A Womans High Calling
Passionate Housewives: Desperate for God
Thriving on One Income
Homeschooling the Teen Years
To Kill a Mockingbird
The Whipping Boy
Culture Warrior
King James Bible


Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Email Me
My Blog's RSS
Homeschool Buyers Co-opHomeschool Helper
Literature Units
Scott Foresman Grammar
WOWIO Free books



Awards and Honors



nicematters

591205076_0b2a8171c3_m




YouMakeMeSmileAward

nominee

hsbabutton-nominee

excellentblog

Graphics from these Sites


Home Sweet HomePage
Freefoto.com

kneeslogo Devotional Doodles

Friends

TOSPUBLISHER
Buckeyeblog
julie
EmptyNestMom
Academy252
ClassicalEducation4Me
HomeschoolLibrarian
sparkshomeschoolmom
PlaidHearts
Lilangels
Debi
DandelionSeeds
redmom


momster
LittleEblingsAcademy
SteveWalden
Hutcheson
joymommy
kkprat
gottsegnet
rondahinzman
FreeStuffForHomeschoolers
hsmomof2
MotherJoy
TerriCamp
iluvtheland
Sawickis
TC
msack
sagerats
SmallWorld
PatinTenn
AnneofGreenGables
barrynmissy1972
debdillon
ElCloud
grace4gayle
Jimmie
mamaforhim
mom2chris
momn4boys
opheliag
homeskoolmom
jaminacema
LovingMyBlessings
WaitingontheLord
deedeeuk
BStrouse
ourhomeschool
JandRlearnathome
heavenlycreations
sarahmomto4kids
humpty
schooldad
DebbieABC
homeiscool
trustingdaily
Peekershaz
helff
juditupp
kidsus8
KimMurphy
mrsdiamond
Glory
Veronica
blueskiesandlemonade
MomsStandStrong
NeverAlone
CelticMom
socalval
Zookeeperof10
CrossView
AHappyHome
AngieMama
tiredmom
bbullard
woodyx
subbertfamily
Leigharev2
servingtheKingofkings
pilgrim
briannash
VAhomeschooljourney
naval
hansmom
joyfulhome
CarmenRosales
weare3
My3BoysHomeschool
midwifemom
BevG
douglashomeskool
giftsfromAdonai
MOMflippedisWOW
ctnjm324

daredhead
Keri
AnneShaw
AngtheFLYingKiwi
mommyof3girlies
pinkginghamom
westward
jenn4him
TeachingHisWays
mom45angels
eclecticeducation
mom2kateandella
FruitfulFamily
CandaceC
babean
4sweetums
ddmcnair
partyoffive
cricket
nikkisimcox

vikingsfan
MOMatHWTK
sockmonkey
momzilla
homegrownhomeschool
HFC
maurreyaugust
pottershand
bfdelph
gnjlopez
mykidsmatter2
2girlsand2boys
thesuparats
roxy1972
WisdomBuilders
HSBiz
geeterbug5
msvmac
jenefork
blessedwith2angels
loreo

southmsmomof4
Mom2PCAJD
christinejoy
mom2many
ChristLover
deeva58
stormie726
Bethany897
ilovemy3angelbabies
addiema
funlearning
kancel
mssuccess14
SchoolinRhome
dovie
Waldens
nursegingermom
Autumn
dukygurl
detweilermom
mamaof4
needhisgrace
Onnie76
sheagang6
Debbie4
Momto4nmore
ccparker
Entry 233 of 505
Last Page | Next Page


Other Blogs I visit

Grace for Gayle
i have to say
It Coulda' Been Worse
It's all for the best
Happy Hearts at Home
My Lil' Corner of the World
Shades of Pink
Finding Contentment in the Suburbs
Stop the Ride
Why Homeschool
The Frugal Kitchen
In the midst of it
Hope-n-Grace for Sunny Days
At Table
Tammy's Recipes
Notes from the laundry pile
Deb on the run
A Joyful Keeper of the Home
Homeschooling and
The Power of One
Glimpse of Sonshine
HomeschoolBuzz


Hit Counter Free Web Counter
Web Counters Homeschool Gold