Two Kid Schoolhouse

• Feb. 5, 2006 - Valentines And The Feminization Of Boys

Our homeschool group is planning a Valentine's Day party.  It sounds kind of fun - some craft projects, and lots of free time to play basketball or whatever in a gym.  Oh, and good snacks.  But I don't think we can go.

The party includes a valentine card exchange among all the kids - about 22 of them, as far as I can tell, boys and girls, from age 13 or so down to babies.
  Right from the start, something bothered me about it but I couldn't quite figure it out. 

Is it the randomness of it?   Everyone has to bring a card for everyone else.  Even if they don't know everyone.  There's no emotion attached to this card at all.  Everyone just ends up with... a pile of cards.

When each of 22 kids gets a card saying "You're Special!" - how special is that?

Is it the hassle?  I hate the dippy valentine cards available in the stores.  My kids don't watch Scooby Doo or Dora the Explorer, so they don't want those cards, but that's what there is!   Making cards would suck up too much of our time.  I want the kids to spend their time making valentines for Daddy, Grandma and Grandpa, each other, and me! 

Actually, those are my minor reasons.   The real problem is this: the femininity of it.   Exchanging valentines among friends seems very feminine to me.  I can remember as a single working gal, giving cute, flippant valentines to some of my single friends.  It's a girl thing.  E would love this. In fact, the little girls of the group are having a tea party the day before, where they will exchange valentines!  She is thrilled.   J is thrilled that he doesn't have to go - he doesn't like tea parties.  But the point is:  Men don't exchange valentine cards.  At least, I don't know any, and neither does my husband (who agrees with me). 


That doesn't mean I don't want my son to grow up to acknowledge Valentine's Day with his wife.  I hope he'll enjoy getting homemade valentines from his own kiddies some day.  I enjoy giving (and getting) cards to (and from) my loved ones - husband, kids.  My sister sometimes sends me one.  I sometimes (not often) send one to her.  But not random buddies, you know?

Oh, heavy sigh.  
The feminization of our boys is pervasive, even among Christian homeschoolers.  Or maybe I'm just taking this too seriously? 
Post A Comment! :: Send to a Friend!

• Feb. 6, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by lynan
I agree with you. I kept thinking a party would be fun but there's no way my boys would want to be anywhere near a Valentine's party. Otoh, I remember one year in the Christian school I was in, we had a Laurel and Hardy movie and pizza. Now that was a party for Valentine's Day that I'm sure my boys would enjoy! Apparently I did too, cuz I don't remember any other parties!
Permanent Link

• Feb. 6, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by norwester
Don't they make Spiderman Valentines? Or something of that sort?

I think age would have a lot to do with it too. F. would be absolutely mortified to even think of taking part in a Valentines thing, but I think O. would like it-Especially if people thought to stick a little candy in with the card. :)
Permanent Link

• Feb. 7, 2006 - Thanks for the comment!

Posted by mizmunce
About the 88 cent shirt...You know, my girlfriends and I all pass along our clothes to each other once we're tired of them. When I'm done with my 88 cent shirt, maybe I should send it your way. :-)
Permanent Link

• Feb. 9, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by eyecorn
I'm with ya' on the Valentine's ...especially as the children get past a certain age. My 13 yo would feel very awkward at a paty like that, altho DD would enjoy. I don't think DS needs to be put in that situation. NOw, if it was a paintball Valentine party...where they shoot pink paint, well that's another story!!
Permanent Link

• Feb. 10, 2006 - Untitled Comment

Posted by mamaduso
You seem to be very discerning and intuitive. Stick by your convictions. You are right-I never thought of it that way but it is true-boys don't send valentines to buddies. Weird! And what is the purpose of them sending them to other girls? Nothing really. I have all girls so we do it up but with boys I might do things differently.
Susan
Permanent Link


About Me

Musings of a slacker homeschool Mom
Entry 513 of 665
Last Page | Next Page