Food Allergy News From Our House

• Nov. 17, 2007 - Baking Without Eggs...UGGH!!

Posted in My Thoughts

     We had a birthday party to go to last night, and of course I wanted to make sure we had safe cake of our own to eat.  I do have a chocolate cake recipe that works pretty well, especially for cupcakes.  But, we, (or rather I) am getting tired of plain chocolate cake.  So, I decide that I was going to try something new.

     I have come across some posts that have suggested using a mix of gelatin and some other things (I cannot remember exactly how to do it off the top of my head), in place of using eggs.  Let me just say, baking without eggs is almost impossible!

     I started out yesterday with a box cake mix and this gelatin mixture.  At first, based on what the batter looked like once I mixed it, I thought it was actually going to work!  But, when the timer beeped and I pulled the pans out of the oven, they immediately sank!  I stuck them in the refrigerater, mainly because I know Jello will solidify when it gets cold.  But, low and behold, in my opinion it was a failure!

     I then got on the internet to try to search for an eggless cake recipe that was not chocolate.  I found many, but some of them I could tell would probably not turn out right.  I settled for one that included a ton of butter along with raisins, and many spices like cinnamon, cloves, and ginger.  Again, I had high hopes.

     I pulled the spice/raisin cake out of the oven.  It appeared to look like it might work.  The only problem this time was that we had to go, but the cake had to cool before we could cut it!  (Yes, it was a bad moment in the Perry house!) 

     I decided to check on the gelatin cupcakes that I had stuffed in the fridge.  I tasted one, and YUCK!  To me it tasted like a sticky, squishy, muck with barely any flavor!  Randy happened to be in the kitchen and witnessed this.  He begged me for a cupcake.  I tried to tell him that they were no good, but he wouldn't give in.  So, I slapped some chocolate icing on top of one and gave it to him.  He actually told me that he liked it a lot!  He told me that he had to take this kind to the party. 

     I guess this is where the blessing in disguise part comes in.  Had Randy experience any kind of good cake, (or just any other cake for that matter), he probably would have never been able to settle on my gooey failure.  That is the thought I am going to leave with.  I am so done with baking without eggs!  (For now, anyway. . .)

Post A Comment!

• Nov. 17, 2007 - <i>Untitled Comment</i>

Posted by MOMatHWTK
I *believe* you can use a regular cake mix and just use any carbonated beverage as your egg replacer. This is actually a diet recipe, perhaps originally from Weight Watchers. Can you use Enger-G egg replacer?

I almost always use applesauce as my egg replacer and have had no problem. I'm not using a regular cake recipe though as we can't use wheat. Perhaps the xanthum gum helps the binding process?

Have you joined Kids With Food Allergies? They can definitely tell you how to bake great egg free cakes. You might also check at FAAN.org for some tips.

The key to baking without eggs is to know what the egg is doing in your recipe- leavening (use a baking soda or carbonated replacer) or binder (use applesauce or something else "sticky). HTH

Sorry your non-chocolate cake didn't work out. :-(

Edited by MOMatHWTK on Nov. 17, 2007 at 11:01 PM
Permanent Link

• Nov. 18, 2007 - Reply

Posted by amyperry
Yes, I do have a membership with KWFA, that is actually where I got the recipe for the gelatin egg replacer. I did use it with a box cake mix, so maybe that is why it didn't turn out. It worked for the binding part, but the cake sank and had a gelatin flavor.

I did look on FAAN's site for recipes as well as all over the internet. I will say, that yesterday I had a piece of the spice/raisin cake and it actually tasted good. So, maybe it just needed to cool first.

The chocolate cake recipe that I use actually works well, we are just sick of chocolate! I would love to try the apple sauce idea. Would you mind sharing?

Oh, and the Ener-G egg Replacer has never worked for binding. . .

Edited by amyperry on Nov. 18, 2007 at 9:11 AM
Permanent Link

• Nov. 19, 2007 - <i>Untitled Comment</i>

Posted by naturalpaths
I tried to leave you a comment earlier today and my computer froze just as I was posting. Let's see if I can get it to go through this time...

Is ground flaxseed meal something that you can try? I came across this info a year or so ago - http://www.flaxcouncil.ca/english/index.php?p=meal&mp=nutrition

I used to use soy flour in place of eggs when baking, but we wanted to get soy out of our diet as much as possible so I gave the ground flaxseed a go. So far it's worked just fine with no taste difference. The only thing I've noticed is it will leave brown flecks throughout the finished product (any light-colored product). I have to admit as well that I do not combine the flaxseed meal and water and let it set to gel as the site says. I am always in a hurry so I am very much a "dump it all in together" kind of baker - no problems yet with doing it that way.

Edited by naturalpaths on Nov. 19, 2007 at 12:11 PM
Permanent Link

• Nov. 20, 2007 - Here's the recipe I start with...

Posted by MOMatHWTK
then I modify it a lot. :-)

Banana Cake
Dry ingredients-
1.5 cups rice flour
1/2 cup of sugar
1 teaspoon baking soda
1/4 teaspoon vitamin C crystals (unbuffered vit C) *
mix in a large bowl then in a large measuring cup, add together:
1/4 cup oil
2 large bananas, mashed
dash of xanthum gum
mix into the bowl with dry ingredients add about 2 tablespoons of apple juice* or slightly more until the mixture is moist put into muffin tins or 8" cake pan bake for about 25-30 minutes at 350 degrees until golden brown.

*(I substitute 2-3 T orange juice for the apple juice and vit C)

The baking soda/vitamin C is your leavening agent. If you can use baking powder, you can just sub that and skip vitamin C. I sometimes use banana, sometimes applesauce- this is your binder ingredient. I also use a blend of rice and oat flour. You can use wheat though, right? So I guess that means you can skip that complication as well. LOL!

Basically, I throw in about 1/3 to 1/2 applesauce for each egg and wing it. BUT my son has never had anything else so he doesn't know what wheat/egg/dairy cake tastes like. :-)


I would guess that your chocolate cake recipe will work without the cocoa (or whatever you are using to make it chocolate). Try using just vanilla or some other flavor instead of the cocoa.


Scroll down on this blog until you get to the "soda cake" entry for information on using a soft drink as your egg replacer in a cake mix:
http://imhelendt.wordpress.com/recipes/

Here's the simple soda cake recipe:
http://www.tinkertech.net/recipes/archives/2004/12/diet_soda_cake.html

You can use regular soda, not just diet.

HTH

Edited by MOMatHWTK on Nov. 20, 2007 at 5:07 AM
Permanent Link

• Nov. 20, 2007 - Thank You HWTK

Posted by amyperry
I appreciate you taking the time to share these tips with me. As soon as I get a chance to get back in my kitchen to experiment, I will give these a try.

I have come across the ingredient for xanthum gum a number of times. Where can I find it? I am assuming it is used for the binding process?

Thanks again!
Permanent Link

About Me

This blog will be used to communicate news on the topic of food allergies. Some of the details will be general where as others will be specifically about my son, Randy. I welcome all comments.

Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Email Me
Our Homeschool Blog
FAAST
Emily Vonder Muellen
Food Allergy Initiative
Food Allergy Project
FAAN
Gaks Snacks
Enjoy Life Foods
No Nuttin'
Allergy Kids
Kids With Food Allergies
Our Homeschool Blog
Bakin' Without Eggs by Rosemarie Emro
Kyle Dine's Music

Friends

/HWTK/
/prayingforgrace/

Entry 6 of 37
Last Page | Next Page