Rose in the Wilderness

Aug. 12, 2009

More Thoughts on Fiction: Advice From a Novice, part II

So my last post was a little bit short and blunt, because I'm afraid I've scared readers away with my previous long ones. I read it over this morning and it felt abrupt. Maybe I can reach a happy medium today.


Now you know about the Telling problem, so I can move on to another biggie: Head Hopping—also known as POV Violation. (POV stands for Point of View.)


There are three major POV styles. They're called:

1st Person—Written as if the main character is actually the one telling the story. Jane Eyre is a good example of this.

“I jumped up, took my muff and umbrella, and hastened into the inn-passage: a man was standing by the open door, and in the lamp-lit street I dimly saw a one-horse conveyance.”

Notice the, “I”? That's 1st Person. You're in one person's head through at least a certain scene or chapter, if not the whole book. You see things only as the character sees them, and you know only his or her thoughts. This style is not the easiest of the three, but it is such a good read.


2nd Person—“You did this, and you said that.” This style is pretty hard to make look good, and it's uncommon to find in novels. I hear it's been done, but I've never read it. We'll leave that one there.


3rd Person. This is the most popular and easiest of the three. It is written as if the narrator is telling a story about the main character. “She did this,” or, “He said that.” There are lots and lots of authors who write this way—Jane Austen, C. S. Lewis, Tolkien, Louisa May Alcott, to name a couple of examples. We're going to park here for a while, because this is where the issue of Head-Hopping rises.

Head Hopping: A weak writing technique in which the author skips from one character's thoughts and perspective to another's without appropriate pause.

I was browsing through a book in the YA section of the library the other day. The female character was looking at the male character, and she was noting the color of his eyes.

THEN, all of a sudden, we find the male character looking at the female character, noting the color of HER eyes!

This is a really confusing thing to do when writing a novel, and jars the reader from the story. When a reader picks up a book for the first time, he often doesn't care one way or another about it. He's thinking, “Hmm—wonder if this is any good?” The task of the first few pages is to reach out and grab his attention, pull it in, and keep it there. A POV violation is like a speed bump that makes the reader think, “Hold on—what? Now we're over here with THIS guy? Weren't we just...and who is...HUH?”

It may not be that extreme, and he may figure it out very quickly and settle in again. In fact, he may barely even notice that it happened. But it did. And focus, once broken, isn't as easily captured the second time.

Think of words as doors. He opens the cover. Grabs the doorknob. Opens it, and is immediately captured by the actions taking place on the other side. He's watching a...well, a horse-race, shall we say. He sees a horse he likes. Decides to root for it. Is just watching it glide towards the finish...

When he realizes that he's still standing at the doorway.

You DON'T want to draw attention to the doorway when the race is where you're trying to catch the eye.

You know how with tour buses, they have rules against sticking hands out the windows, or jumping out before the bus stops? It's the same thing in fiction. A stop can be a scene break, a chapter break, the break between parts one and two, or two books in a series. But don't get out and find another character's thoughts to hang out in 'till the bus has stopped.


Let me know how it works for you.




Post A Comment! Send to a Friend!

Comments

Aug. 12, 2009 - Untitled Comment

Posted by Kayla
Great tip! In real life you only get one point of view, and often it can be a big conflict when you don't know the point of view of the other person. So when you take that conflict away (which fiction thrives on!), you're also taking away the thrill. It's kind of the same concept as "Show, don't tell" which you mentioned in your last post.
Permanent Link

Aug. 16, 2009 - Untitled Comment

Posted by David
There is, though, a possibility of switching POV's without destroying the effect. Remember how Bram Stoker switched POV's chapter by chapter, and I have read books where this was done in sub-chapter sections.
Permanent Link

Aug. 17, 2009 - Untitled Comment

Posted by LadyMaie
Kayla,
Thanks a lot!

David,
Absolutely. In my novel I switch POV's from chapter to chapter, and sometimes from scene to scene. Note what I said: (roughly) "Head-Hopping is when the author switches from one character's POV to another's WITHOUT APPROPRIATE PAUSE." A pause can be a chapter-ending, a scene-ending, or whatever. But there has to be something that says, "Be notified: something is changing now."

***
Like that. :-) That's what I was saying about bus-stops. I didn't say that nobody could get off until the bus was done for the day (I.E. the novel is over). There have to be appropriate pauses. In the example I was speaking of, there were no pauses at all. It was a straight hop from the female to the male in about two paragraphs. It was really annoying.

That's what I'm meaning.
~H
Permanent Link

About Me

In which I post my eclectic thoughts on what I feel is important to me, and which I think others might benefit from.

Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Email Me
My Blog's RSS

Friends

TOSPUBLISHER
HSBCompanyBlog
BookwormMN
BreezyTulip
thegatekeeper
Anna93
Tessa
godzwilla
radiantpurity
Entry 5 of 19
Last Page | Next Page