Classically Speaking...

May. 30, 2006

He has a point...

I read an interesting article in The Link Homeschoolg Newspaper the other day.  I think it was an old copy of the paper, but the article was well worth reading, and you can find it here.

It was a piece, by John Taylor Gatto, on the comments made by Bill Gates, regarding college.
In a fascinating article, Gatto goes on to tell us about the ideal utopian dream... college for everyone.  Then he points out... it's a dream worth so little.
So many of our entrepeneurs are college drop-outs... couldn't even get through it.
I, consider it hope for myself being as I never finished either!

I loved this part:


I asked my hosts to consider this: If Gates' proposal was such a great idea, then how was it that Gates, like Faulkner, dropped out of college his freshman year? And why didn't he ever go back? And how was it that from among millions of college-trained techies, Gates decided to hook up with another dropout, Paul Allen, to found Microsoft?

That could have been a million-to-one coincidence, of course, except for the fact that Steve Jobs, the brains behind Apple, dropped out of Reed College after one semester. And never went back to college, not for a single day! Was it only an accident that Jobs chose to partner with another dropout, Steve Wozniak, in the founding of Apple?

Michael Dell of Dell Computer didn't bother with college either. Larry Ellison, CEO of Oracle, said he didn't have the time to waste on college. Is the penny beginning to drop? These multi-billionaires, who've changed the face of the global society in technology, were all dropouts. What do you make of that?

Ted Turner, founder of CNN was pitched out of college on his ear, flunked out just like Al Gore did at Vanderbilt. Ray Kroc of McDonald's told his mother at age 15 that he didn't have time to waste on high school, dropping out at almost the same age that the female auto-racing phenomenon, Danica Patrick did. Danica dropped out at 16, went to London on her own (just like Benjamin Franklin did two and a half centuries ago) and signed herself into a course on how to sustain speeds above 200 mph on a racetrack!




Then there was this:


Saturation schooling, kindergarten through college, was a leadership response to the demands of a centralized corporate economy that replaced American/Canadian entrepreneurialism between 1880 and 1920.

What corporatism required was two things: A laboring mass - including a professional laboring mass of doctors, lawyers, engineers, architects and schoolteachers - who did what they were told without question, and a citizenry in name only, one which defined itself by non-stop consumption, one which believed that choosing between options offered by management was what democracy was all about.

Lockstep schooling, driven by standardized testing, testing not to measure learning but obedience, was the mechanism used to drive out imagination and courage. It worked and still works superbly, but, like the little mill that ground salt when salt wasn't needed, this brilliant utopian construction is about to kill us.

North American economies dazzled the world for centuries because they encouraged resourcefulness, individuality and risk-taking to dominate the marketplace, and these qualities were encouraged in everyone, not just in the elites.

Three North American commercial juggernauts are currently blowing away competition all over China: computer hardware and programming, fast food franchising and commercial entertainment (singing, dancing, story-telling, games and all the rest).

Each of these businesses is almost exclusively the work of dropouts, from college, high school and elementary school. They are erected from imagination. Our fast food franchises don't really sell "food" at all, but two intense tastes - salty and sweet - surrounded by clean, well-lighted places and spotless toilets and primary colors. They sell a return to early childhood and its simplicities.



He has a point... our education in this country has suffered... the utopian ideals suggested by Bill Gates are the sort that will cripple us... because of companies like his own... which educate then hire the masses in developing countries... they cost a lot less.
Besides... surely what is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander?  If it is good enough for him, then why not the rest of us?


Post A Comment! Send to a Friend!

Comments

May. 30, 2006 - heee

Posted by Dana
i have TWO JT Gatto books sitting on my TBR table
i feel lots of rants coming on!
YAY
Permanent Link

May. 31, 2006 - Must reads

Posted by Anonymous
John Taylor Gatto's book "Dumbing Us Down" and Oliver DeMille's book "A Thomas Jefferson Education" are the key for really understanding and addressing these issues. So often as homeschoolers we take our kids out of public school and set up a mini public school in our kitchens. There is more at stake here than academics. The formation of character is what it's all about for me.

Just FYI you can buy both of these books at:

http://www.gwc.edu/bookstore/cgi-bin/cp-app.pl?usr=51F6385498&rnd=4347839&rrc=N&affl=&cip=24.2.109.88&act=&aff=&pg=cat&ref=8

I'm not offiliated with them or anything. Just trying to be helpful.
Thanks for the great article!
Emily Clawson
http://www.barefootpixie.mbdblog.com
Permanent Link

About Me

I'm a 29 year old mother of two, who loves to read, bake, knit and homeschool... You can also read my husband's 'rantings' at the link below ;)


I am currently having problems blogging here. Please check
my nature blog for more information.
Nature Blog

Entry 58 of 214
Last Page | Next Page