Classically Speaking...

Aug. 3, 2006

BOOK REVIEW: Crunchy Cons

Crunchy Cons:
How Birkenstocked Burkeans, gun-loving organic gardeners, evangelical free-range farmers, hip homeschooling mamas, right-wing nature lovers, ... America (or at least the Republican Party)


By Rod Dreher



This book was a fascinating read into the life of someone who calls himself a Crunchy Conservative and I had to admit it was rather thought provoking.
Coming from England, the one and only time I voted, I voted for the Labour Party which is halfway between the American Republican and the American Democratic parties.  This has always made it difficult for me to affiliate with any one party over here- not a big deal since I cannot legally vote as I am not a citizen!
So you can imagine my surprize when in the course of a day, this book pops up twice in conversation.  I immediately get a copy to read.
Dreher begins his book by describing Crunchy Conservatives, their beliefs in certain areas and illustrates these with profiles and conversations of crunchy cons in real life.
In this case, for those who do not know, Crunchy is a term used to describe the kind of person who makes their own granola (muesli in the UK)... hence crunchy.  Typically people who do so are very much the kind who care for the environment, eat organic foods, HOMESCHOOL, grow their own food, follow the slow food movement and support the liberal political parties.  In this case, Dreher points out that there are a number of Republicans out there who do these things too, except they support the Republican party.
Dreher tells us that crunchy cons are CONSERVATIONIST in that they believe in land stewardship, and do not support strip mining, mountaintop removal or the overuse of chemicals.  Crunchy cons are supporters of small businesses and agri-business and do not want whatever big business wants.
Crunchy cons support family and the family meal, quality family time and deplore McMansions...
Truth be told, many of these philosophies apply to our family!  We homeschool, try to eat organic, support the local farmers by buying produce locally, have a smaller house than most and always eat our homecooked food together.

The book has a number of well taken points, although Dreher can get a little preachy and lecturish at times, but his points are non-the-less valid for all that.  I can be hard not to get that way when people do not listen!  Similarly he can also be self contradicting.
It is far from being a book that will change the world, but it could easily make you think twice on your beliefs, and although not especially original fare, it is interesting.

*** 3 Stars- a worthy read, but be prepared to take what he says lightly, not everyone will agree with him.  Amazingly, the crunchy con precepts even tied into the whole Simple Elegance thread...
Post A Comment! Send to a Friend!

Comments

Aug. 4, 2006 - I'm so glad you posted this

Posted by Lora K.
Yesterday while reading another blog I came across this title about 3 times. I thought it was some type of nick name and that I was way out of the loop. This looks like a book for me. Everything you have described is how we feel about things. It's nice to know that we're not all alone in our thoughts on these topics. I have used all my holds at the library, so I will have to wait until my run this afternoon to order it in.

Have a blessed day!
Permanent Link

Aug. 5, 2006 - Good review

Posted by Jill
You managed to catch just how I felt about this book. We are also Crunchy by his definition, but he does get preachy and in my opinion rather elitist. This last made me so angry that I actually did not finish the book! I also used to read his blog until he made some really nasty comments about evangelical christians one day. As you and I have often discussed, there are people who are not following God in many faiths, but he seems to have the opinion that all Evangelicals are bad. That is sad in many ways.
Permanent Link

About Me

I'm a 29 year old mother of two, who loves to read, bake, knit and homeschool... You can also read my husband's 'rantings' at the link below ;)


I am currently having problems blogging here. Please check
my nature blog for more information.
Nature Blog

Entry 40 of 214
Last Page | Next Page