Classically Speaking...
Sep. 15, 2006

REALLY Good Books

There are a few books in my life that I consider really good.  Invariably they are the books which inspire me to sit and think for days, to contemplate what might happen next, and to go online and try and find out more.
The very best books will leave a lasting impression with me, and years later, I will think back to them.
My list of very best books is short... my list of inspiring books is a little longer... and my list of good-but-not-great books longer still.

I just spend every day Sunday through Thursday, reading the Harry Potter series.  For a modern, children's series, it is excellent.  For a fantasy series, it is excellent.
I find Rowling to be a talented writer, and suddenly, the series is on my 'best' books list.
I ponder the plotline.  I ask questions and try to find out the answers online... and I sit fidgeting, wondering when the next book will come out.
I cannot recall if I was this way after reading each book individually, but when read together, they pack a powerful punch.  They tell a tale of the sorrow of death and loss that many modern stories lack, preferring instead to baby the children and let them think all can be made whole again.  The Harry Potter series doesn't do that... people die, and are dead in the book.
Something our family has had to deal with a lot recently, and that really added to the character and understanding of my children, without messing them up for life, the way many people seem to think it will.
The books pose questions about appearances and personality, and good versus bad.  They ask us to look within ourselves, hiding some modern prejudices underneath the veil of wizardry.
Like all of my best books, they are eminently rereadable, the mark of a great work, for I dispute anyone who might say that a good book is only read once.
Perhaps my favourite aspect of the book, is the way the characters actually develop... how by the end of book 6, Harry is most definitely a man... and I mean this in his ability to take charge and make choices, standing up for what he knows is right... not in any other sense!  He matures with the books, coming from a bad background, shielded by innocence, until the 6th book, where he has become hardened... almost desperate in a way.
This was also one of the things I liked about the other books on my list (Bible excepted)... each of them developed the characters, maturing them and making them suffer.
Least you think I am someone who enjoys suffering, I will tell you that the books often make me cry.  The last HP one did... an ending I had hoped not to see, but realised how much it had to happen.
But, I ramble here... speaking aloud the thoughts that flood into my mind because the book has filled it so far.

On a final note, I will say that those who try to shield their children from this book, do them and it a disservice.  With careful thought, one might use this as one would a fairytale, to illustrate certain facts of life.  While I certainly do not recommend it for younger readers, I do not see where witholding it from them might get you... for that which is forbidden always holds the most attraction.  Treat it with the same respect you do other fiction works and make sure to tell everyone that it is fiction... and that even the author doesn't believe in Harry style magic!

So what other books are on my list?
The Chronicles of Narnia by C.S. Lewis
The Belgariad and Mallorean by David (and Leigh) Eddings
The Bible (you all know who this is by!!)
The Harry Potter Series
The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings by Tolkien

Close contenders would be The Brother Cadfael mysteries by Ellis Peters and The Sister Fidelma mysteries by Peter Tremayne.

If you would like to read more about what is going to happen in the Harry Potter series, try these links:

J.K. Rowling's Website

The Leaky Cauldron
MuggleNet

Comments (1) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Aug. 3, 2006

A Collection of Links to Interest you...

Great post by Elizabeth Foss over at Real Learning.
An interesting CM Bible Study (you can download a free sample).
A Zucchini Cake Recipe (Courgettes for us English folks)
The Crunchy Con Blog.
Light on Dark Water, Maclin Horton's Website and Blog is a great read.
Caelum et Terra website and Blog.
Strange E-Zine The New Pantagruel.
The Charlotte Mason Blog... in her own words.



Comments (2) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Aug. 3, 2006

BOOK REVIEW: Crunchy Cons

Crunchy Cons:
How Birkenstocked Burkeans, gun-loving organic gardeners, evangelical free-range farmers, hip homeschooling mamas, right-wing nature lovers, ... America (or at least the Republican Party)


By Rod Dreher



This book was a fascinating read into the life of someone who calls himself a Crunchy Conservative and I had to admit it was rather thought provoking.
Coming from England, the one and only time I voted, I voted for the Labour Party which is halfway between the American Republican and the American Democratic parties.  This has always made it difficult for me to affiliate with any one party over here- not a big deal since I cannot legally vote as I am not a citizen!
So you can imagine my surprize when in the course of a day, this book pops up twice in conversation.  I immediately get a copy to read.
Dreher begins his book by describing Crunchy Conservatives, their beliefs in certain areas and illustrates these with profiles and conversations of crunchy cons in real life.
In this case, for those who do not know, Crunchy is a term used to describe the kind of person who makes their own granola (muesli in the UK)... hence crunchy.  Typically people who do so are very much the kind who care for the environment, eat organic foods, HOMESCHOOL, grow their own food, follow the slow food movement and support the liberal political parties.  In this case, Dreher points out that there are a number of Republicans out there who do these things too, except they support the Republican party.
Dreher tells us that crunchy cons are CONSERVATIONIST in that they believe in land stewardship, and do not support strip mining, mountaintop removal or the overuse of chemicals.  Crunchy cons are supporters of small businesses and agri-business and do not want whatever big business wants.
Crunchy cons support family and the family meal, quality family time and deplore McMansions...
Truth be told, many of these philosophies apply to our family!  We homeschool, try to eat organic, support the local farmers by buying produce locally, have a smaller house than most and always eat our homecooked food together.

The book has a number of well taken points, although Dreher can get a little preachy and lecturish at times, but his points are non-the-less valid for all that.  I can be hard not to get that way when people do not listen!  Similarly he can also be self contradicting.
It is far from being a book that will change the world, but it could easily make you think twice on your beliefs, and although not especially original fare, it is interesting.

*** 3 Stars- a worthy read, but be prepared to take what he says lightly, not everyone will agree with him.  Amazingly, the crunchy con precepts even tied into the whole Simple Elegance thread...
Comments (2) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Jul. 21, 2006

A few BOOK REVIEWS to keep you going.

So I have read a few books this week... and I debated whether to review them all, if at all, but decided I should!

Last Child in the Woods:

Saving Our Children from Nature-Deficit Disorder




by Richard Louv

This book disappointed me.  It had great promise, and it had a valid point.  What it also had, was an agenda.  It is unfortunate when an author decides to fill a book with their political views, because so often (unless it is a political book and you want the views) they colour your perception of the topic.
Louv coloured his topic, with his environmentalist views, and I was turned off to a lot of what he had to say.
The trouble is, he had a real and valid argument to present.
The book tells us of the change in our perception towards the outdoors and how, where many years ago a parent would let their child roam outside, they willl not today.  How large suburban subdivisions, with covenants, govern our children's ability to play, telling them where and when and even what they can and cannot do.
He tells us that ADHD can be controlled with time in nature, that children need the outdoors to be healthy.
I can't say I disagree, and indeed, I performed an experiment myself.  OK, so it didn't start out being an experiment, just a weather caused experiment!
Monday and Tuesday, I let the kids out to play in the garden... on their own or while I was outside but not directing them.  Wednesday and Thursday, a little heat directed, we stayed inside (getting outside early would appear to be the key here).  Trust me, I much preferred the hyper, but obedient kids of the first two days than the mischeivous kids of the latter two!
Is this conclusive?  No... but I do know if we dont take a walk, my two year old doesnt sleep!
The truth is, this is a great argument for more outdoor time for children, I agree, they should be outdoors more often.  If, on the other hand, you are a fan of Charlotte Mason, and you schedule Nature Study and spend lots of time outside, it is really preaching to the choir.  If you are a CM fan who doesnt get out regularly, you should read it.  Just be ready to take the politics with a pinch of salt!

I give it a ***3 Star rating.  A good book, but not one I'd tell you to buy.

On a different note, a few beach reads to suggest!  I am a fan of Jude Deveraux's novels... she is an author of a genre I have always loved to read... the somewhat gothic style of romance novels out there.  I say somewhat gothic, because she is not really as gothic as say, Victoria Holt or Mary Stewart can be, but I highly recommend their books and Deveraux's too.



First on my list was Forever, the first book in the forever and always trilogy.  A book about psychic Darci Monroe and Adam Montgomery... the pair team up to fight some evil witches.  A light hearted read.  I read it because I had read the other two, but never this one!

*** 3 Stars, not her best novel, but definitely an enjoyable read!



Next up was The Mulberry Tree.  I chose to read this one because it was excepted in the back of Forever, but it was by far the better novel.
When Lillian's husband dies, she is left with nothing but an old farmhouse in Virginia.  She changes her identity and discover's how to live alone.  Charged by her dead husband to find out the truth, she has to discover what lies beneath the surface of the history of her inheritance.

**** 4 Stars because I rather enjoyed this entertaining read!



last on my list was Wild Orchids, a paranormal romance.  Writer Ford Newcombe is taken by a story told by Jackie Maxwell, how a woman is pressed for loving the Devil.  Having suffered a case of write's block since the death of his wife Pat, he sets off to the town of North Carolina to find out the truth.  With Jackie along as his assistant, the two of them learn a lot more about life, love, and small towns than they bargined for.

**** 4 stars... the scene at the end is my favourite, and made the book for me!
Comments (3) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Jul. 13, 2006

BOOK REVIEW: Perelandra

Perelandra

by C.S. Lewis




This is the sequel to the fabulous Out of the Silent Planet. Unlike the first in the trilogy,  Perelandra is more of a theological stufy than a science fiction novel.
Our hero, Elwin Ransom is back, but this time he is transported to the planet Perelandra for a reason which later becomes clear... but I dont want to spoil it for you!
The religious allusions in this book are very obvious, especially the battle between good and evil ensues.
Once more, Lewis provides some thought provoking instances, some questions on humanity and theology that are sure to have people thinking twice.

This book I did not like as well as Out of the Silent Planet... it is just as well written and entertaining, but like I said before... the 'Sci-fi' factor is a little reduced.  Kind of like reading the Voyage of the Dawntreader after reading The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe... the books are both great, both get a high rating, but TLTW&TW is better!
**** ½ (4 ½) Stars... but only because I thought the first was better!
Comments (1) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Jul. 6, 2006

BOOK REVIEW: Out of the Silent Planet

Out Of The Silent Planet

By C.S. Lewis





I have long been a fan of Lewis' Chronicles of Narnia, but it has taken me until now to read this, the first book in his Space Trilogy.
I am not sure why I waited so long, although I do know that at least one previous attempt to get the books from the library ended in frustration because they were all out.
The story is about a Professor called Ransome who, through accidental means, ends up travelling to the planet Malacandria, and meeting the various forms of life there.
Ransome is a likeable character, vividly depicted and based on Lewis' friend, J.R.R. Tolkien.  He is sympathetically depicted, flaws and all.
Those who are fans of science fiction will love the book, as will fans of Lewis' Chronicles of Narnia, I know I did!
It was a book that demanded attention once finished, as I sat there digesting it in silence, pondering the story which had been laid before me.

I give it  ***** 5 Stars and am off to order book 2 from the library.  Definitely worth reading!
Comments (1) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Jun. 28, 2006

BOOK REVIEW: Walking Across Egypt

Walking Across Egypt

by Clyde Edgerton



This book is a beautifully written slice of life, that of Mattie Riggsbee, a 78 year old senior citizen, who is "just slowing down a bit".
A gifted cook, Mattie is a nice old lady, a little naive, and involved in her church.
The book tells the story of a short period in her life, where things just seem to keep happening.
The book is classified Young Adult, which seems a little odd to me, as it is definitely not YA!  It is a well written piece about the difficulties of getting old, and yet makes you think of Grandmothers.
One cannot help but feel a little sorry for Mattie... not because she is getting old, but more because of the other things that happen to her!
This book was not my usual pace of things... it is very short though, and easy to read.
I give it **** 4 Stars for being well written, even though I don't know if I would read any more books by this author.  If you like this style of book, you will LOVE Walking Across Egypt.

Comments (1) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Jun. 22, 2006

BOOK REVIEW: The Historian


The Historian





by Elizabeth Kostova

This is the second large novel I have attacked in as many weeks... and devoured in just two days.
This is the firts book by kostova, and it is quite a read!  The book is incredibly complicated, there are times when you are reading a story, within a story, within the book itself.

So what is it about?
Vlad the impaler or as he was otherwise known: Dracula... which apparently means The Dragon or Son of the Dragon depending on the context of the book.  It is a well written trip across cold war Europe, a broad sweep reaching from America, through England and France and on into Turkey, Hungary and Bulgaria.
There are two main characters, in two different times, telling their two different stories, as they converge together.  The only disappointment I had, was that it was sometimes hard to differentiate true history from fiction... but then again, isn't that the aim of every author? :)

The book made me want to learn a lot more about the Ottoman empire and it's domination of eastern Europe, and I couldn't help but be amused by the similarities of what was happening in the 15th century, to the Christian/Muslim debates of today.  It's an interesting angle anyway :)

I highly recommend those who do wish to read it, read Bram Stoker's Dracula first or at least concurrently with it, as this actually features in the story quite a bit.  Although I have not read it, I have read derivations which helped, but I cant help but think the novel itself rates as a good background read!

I rate it **** 4 stars... not quite as memorable as Ireland, but every bit as well written!
Comments (2) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Jun. 15, 2006

BOOK REVIEW: Ireland, A Novel

Ireland, a Novel

by Frank Delaney




This fantastic books is a melding of the timeline, a mixture of truth, folklore and history that any lover of the Emerald Isle would delight to read.
I am a great lover of folklore... I was raised on fairy tales and mystery/adventure books and I *still* loved to read them... and this book has a little of everything.
It is the story of a boy... who becomes a man.  It is the tale of his life, and of the extraordinary people who shaped it.  It is his story interspersed with folklore and history.
It is well written, from every angle, and a fascinating look into the lives of the Irish.  This English Catholic was moved to tears when she read about what her countrymen had done to the Irish Catholics...

If you love Ireland, you will love this book.
A hearty read, it is definitely a long one!

***** 5 Stars.

See the author's site at http://www.frankdelaney.com/

And book recommendations would be gratefully accepted... as my Summer Reading Challenge is to read at least 5 books recommended by others.  I am very picky, so please, read on!!
Comments (2) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


May. 31, 2006

BOOK REVIEW: The Latin Centered Curriculum

The Latin Centered Curriculum
by Andrew Campbell

 

My Book finally arrived yesterday... no, it was not that it took forever to get here, just that I am incredibly impatient and had to await the arrival of the book at the distributor I chose... oh well... at least mine was in great shape thanks to Adoremus Books!

I spent the last day reading it... only a day because half of today was wasted on being distracted by Harry Potter on audio tape... why did I put that in the living room??
The book is fantastic... better by far than the rough draft I got to read a while back and definitely bedside table material.

Basically a how-to manual on giving your child the best education you possibly can, the Latin Centered Curriculum (LCC) is a book that bases it's ideology on the education the Greeks and Romans gave to their kids.
It starts out with apologetics... why you should follow the LCC, and puts forth great arguments both for it and against it's detractors.
Then it tells you how to do it... giving outlines, sample schedules and in depth descriptions of the courses of study and recommended texts.
The most amazing aspect of the book is that it fits all this into 160 pages... (not including the appendices) but then, that is the beauty of of the LCC... the ideal of Much, not many... about which you can read more either in the book itself or here at the Memoria Press Site

I found myself agreeing with the book, nodding my head and thinking with pleasure of all the things my children and I will be learning in the years to come!
It was hard not to get up and start right away... so I planned next year instead
I made a booklist, I ordered some from the library to test them... and I am planning many more things!!

I Rate it a good ***** 5 Stars... a must read for all Classical Homeschoolers!  Drew Campbell has provided us all with an amazing resource.




FWIW... yesterday I linked to the JTG article, and had a couple of comments, one of which recommended reading the JTG 'Dumbing us Down' and 'A Thomas Jefferson Education'.
I have read the TJEd, and in fact do recommend that you try to get hold of a copy of it.  If nothing else, TJEd will tell you why you as a parent should try to improve your education... and when you read the plans in LCC mentioned above, you'll know why I'm telling you to read it!
A parent as a mentor is something we should strive to achieve for our children... and we cannot be mentors if we do not read the books our children read.
And what a list we have to read!

HAPPY READING!!
Comments (3) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


May. 30, 2006

He has a point...

I read an interesting article in The Link Homeschoolg Newspaper the other day.  I think it was an old copy of the paper, but the article was well worth reading, and you can find it here.

It was a piece, by John Taylor Gatto, on the comments made by Bill Gates, regarding college.
In a fascinating article, Gatto goes on to tell us about the ideal utopian dream... college for everyone.  Then he points out... it's a dream worth so little.
So many of our entrepeneurs are college drop-outs... couldn't even get through it.
I, consider it hope for myself being as I never finished either!

I loved this part:


I asked my hosts to consider this: If Gates' proposal was such a great idea, then how was it that Gates, like Faulkner, dropped out of college his freshman year? And why didn't he ever go back? And how was it that from among millions of college-trained techies, Gates decided to hook up with another dropout, Paul Allen, to found Microsoft?

That could have been a million-to-one coincidence, of course, except for the fact that Steve Jobs, the brains behind Apple, dropped out of Reed College after one semester. And never went back to college, not for a single day! Was it only an accident that Jobs chose to partner with another dropout, Steve Wozniak, in the founding of Apple?

Michael Dell of Dell Computer didn't bother with college either. Larry Ellison, CEO of Oracle, said he didn't have the time to waste on college. Is the penny beginning to drop? These multi-billionaires, who've changed the face of the global society in technology, were all dropouts. What do you make of that?

Ted Turner, founder of CNN was pitched out of college on his ear, flunked out just like Al Gore did at Vanderbilt. Ray Kroc of McDonald's told his mother at age 15 that he didn't have time to waste on high school, dropping out at almost the same age that the female auto-racing phenomenon, Danica Patrick did. Danica dropped out at 16, went to London on her own (just like Benjamin Franklin did two and a half centuries ago) and signed herself into a course on how to sustain speeds above 200 mph on a racetrack!




Then there was this:


Saturation schooling, kindergarten through college, was a leadership response to the demands of a centralized corporate economy that replaced American/Canadian entrepreneurialism between 1880 and 1920.

What corporatism required was two things: A laboring mass - including a professional laboring mass of doctors, lawyers, engineers, architects and schoolteachers - who did what they were told without question, and a citizenry in name only, one which defined itself by non-stop consumption, one which believed that choosing between options offered by management was what democracy was all about.

Lockstep schooling, driven by standardized testing, testing not to measure learning but obedience, was the mechanism used to drive out imagination and courage. It worked and still works superbly, but, like the little mill that ground salt when salt wasn't needed, this brilliant utopian construction is about to kill us.

North American economies dazzled the world for centuries because they encouraged resourcefulness, individuality and risk-taking to dominate the marketplace, and these qualities were encouraged in everyone, not just in the elites.

Three North American commercial juggernauts are currently blowing away competition all over China: computer hardware and programming, fast food franchising and commercial entertainment (singing, dancing, story-telling, games and all the rest).

Each of these businesses is almost exclusively the work of dropouts, from college, high school and elementary school. They are erected from imagination. Our fast food franchises don't really sell "food" at all, but two intense tastes - salty and sweet - surrounded by clean, well-lighted places and spotless toilets and primary colors. They sell a return to early childhood and its simplicities.



He has a point... our education in this country has suffered... the utopian ideals suggested by Bill Gates are the sort that will cripple us... because of companies like his own... which educate then hire the masses in developing countries... they cost a lot less.
Besides... surely what is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander?  If it is good enough for him, then why not the rest of us?


Comments (2) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Nov. 15, 2005

More on '84

Sometimes I hate computers.  I had written a lovely post… and then I press a button and it all disappears in a second!

But I’ll try to rewrite my post.


1984 is a fascinating book.  In fact, Orwell himself was a fascinating author.  I was made to read Animal Farm back in school, and like many required books, I hated it.  And was strangely fascinated with it.

Orwell had a gift for writing books that made you uncomfortable.  His style was to bring to the forefront, aspects of the human race that we are not really comfortable with facing.  Both 1984 and Animal Farm were to me both repugnant and compelling.  I didn’t like what he was saying about the human race, but I could not say that I really disagreed with his observations on human nature.

DH and I are a third of the way into the book.  And now, my libertarian leaning husband is paranoid (actually he prefers to call himself a democratic republican after the great man Thomas Jefferson himself).  He already wanted to shoot the cameras on the traffic lights, and he was convinced that every sheriff’s deputy/policeman was after him.  Who can blame him, I was there a few times when they followed him, but I digress.  Now, he is perfectly convinced that Big Brother exists, and is currently known as the government.

As for myself, my fascination for the books stems from the words and phrases Orwell coined, that have made their way into the national lexicon of at least two countries, if not more (Great Britain and the United States just in case you wondered).

It was in the book 1984 that the term Big brother was coined, and now I am seeing it in use everywhere.

I watched Numbers on Friday (I love to laugh at this show)… there was Big Brother mentioned.

I read a blog yesterday… totally unrelated to my reading, and there was the term newspeak.

I have to wonder, how many people have actually read 1984?  And how many use the terminology - without even realizing where it came from?


The truth is, I have been thoroughly enjoying ‘reading’ the book with my husband.  We discuss the chapters we have read/heard, and apply it to the things we see now.

We discussed how the book influenced the ‘B-movie’ They Live (fascinating film), and how recent technological advancements reflect the things Orwell foresaw.

The discussion lead into a diatribe on ‘how modern schools were leaning towards Newspeak’ and ‘how the history books are rewritten’ à la Big Brother.  I am sure there are other similarities out there… we'll just have to keep reading to find out.


I have plans for the future though... and they include going back to
Atlas Shrugged and reading it together...


Comments (0) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Nov. 14, 2005

1984

So Dh and I finally managed to start reading 1984.  Yes, it took that long for the audio book to get into the library.
And it took less than a couple of minutes to entirely freak the two of us out!
Firstly, I have to explain the audio book.  The only time DH had 'free' that he was willing to 'read' along with me, was his ride in the car.  So hence, the audio book (plus he apparently hates fiction).
Now, everywhere we look, we see refereces to 'Big Brother' and spot the similarities to Orwell's world with alarming frequency.
Read the book people... and prepare to be scared!
Comments (5) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


Nov. 3, 2005

The Chosen


I am not  a huge fan of the modern classic novel, and I tend to shy away from them and put off the idea of reading them.  I guess in part that much of my reluctance stems from some bad experiences in school, of being forced to read some dreadful (to me) classics.  So, it was with a definite reluctance that I bought Chaim Potok's The Chosen, and only because A Thomas Jefferson Education insisted on it being a great book did I even get that far.
I put it off a further couple of weeks, and yesterday, in a fit of not knowing what I wanted to read, I started the novel.  I finished it last night.  Yes, I spent the whole afternoon reading it, it was that good.
The books is about two Jewish boys, in World War II New York City.  Narrated in the first person, it describes the lifestyle of both an Orthodox Jew and a non-Orthodox Jew, with strong fathers, and the different way in which they were brought up.
The storyline is not involved, but the smattering of Jewish history and Jewish ways strewn throughout the book gave a fascinating insight into their world.  And an interesting insight into diaspora Jews during World War II.
I was profoundly affected by the book, but if I were asked to give a reason why, I could not tell you.  It was not as though the story were an exciting adventure, yet still, Potok managed to draw me in and keep me interested throughout the 291 pages, and I cant tell you why.  Perhaps it was the glimpse into the life of someone, perhaps it was the way Potok managed to illustrate a realistic and attractive vision.  Beautifully written, the cover artwork doesn't do the story justice.
Comments (0) Post A Comment! Permanent Link


About Me

I'm a 29 year old mother of two, who loves to read, bake, knit and homeschool... You can also read my husband's 'rantings' at the link below ;)


I am currently having problems blogging here. Please check
my nature blog for more information.
Nature Blog

Page 1 of 1
Last Page | Next Page