Need Another Reason to Homeschool?
Nov. 4, 2005 at 5:47 AM
Homeschooling
The schools and now the courts are making it so much easier to make the decision to homeschool.
Joanne Jacobs blogged about a recent court ruling in California. Apparently, in 2002, a few parents sued the Palmdale School District after the school surveyed the children about their thoughts on s*x. The court dismissed the case. The court found that parents have no rights when it comes to what their children are taught. Nor can they do anything if the schools teach something that they object to. Here's what the unaminmous court ruling said (PDF) .
And just how old were the children surveyed? Seven to ten years of age! The program was dropped because of complaints. But with this court ruling it will be interesting to see how the schools respond and what the long term effects of this will be on our society.
I"m amazed that more parents didn't join this suit initially. Have we really gotten to the point where parents are this apathetic and the schools and court this powerful?
This is a case that I hope is appealed. But why wait for the courts to rule - just homeschool. Especially if you live in this California district.
WorldNetDaily and Focus on the Family Citizen Link have written about this ruling as well.
Joanne Jacobs blogged about a recent court ruling in California. Apparently, in 2002, a few parents sued the Palmdale School District after the school surveyed the children about their thoughts on s*x. The court dismissed the case. The court found that parents have no rights when it comes to what their children are taught. Nor can they do anything if the schools teach something that they object to. Here's what the unaminmous court ruling said (PDF) .
We agree, and hold that there is no fundamental right of parents to be the exclusive provider of information regarding sexual matters to their children, either independent of their right to direct the upbringing and education of their children or encompassed by it. We also hold that parents have no due process or privacy right to override the determinations of public schools as to the information to which their children will be exposed while enrolled as students. Finally, we hold that the defendants' actions were rationally related to a legitimate state purpose.Stop and read the two comments in bold again. And then add to that what the court also said in this decision a little further into their opinion.
As the First Circuit made clear in Brown, once parents make the choice as to which school their children will attend, their fundamental right to control the education of their childrenis, at the least, substantially diminished. The constitution does not vest parents with the authority to interfere with a public school's decision as to how it will provide information to its students or what information it will provide, in its classrooms or otherwise. See Yoder, 406 U.S. at 205.Can it be any clearer? The court is looking at the whole issue from the perspective of what is best for the state. And teaching s*x and surveying elementary school children is in their best interest and rational. NOT the child's or the parent's. The interest of the state appears to be the highest concern.
We further hold that a psychological survey is a reasonable state action pursuant to legitimate educational as well as health and welfare interests of the state.The welfare of the state? The schools are making it easier and easier to outsource parenting. And now the court is making it legitimate. When will parents wake up and see what's going on? The court has just ruled that the parent does not have any authority to interere with the public school's decisions about what to teach and what information it will provide . And parents think THEY are going to reform the schools. Dream on!
And just how old were the children surveyed? Seven to ten years of age! The program was dropped because of complaints. But with this court ruling it will be interesting to see how the schools respond and what the long term effects of this will be on our society.
I"m amazed that more parents didn't join this suit initially. Have we really gotten to the point where parents are this apathetic and the schools and court this powerful?
This is a case that I hope is appealed. But why wait for the courts to rule - just homeschool. Especially if you live in this California district.
WorldNetDaily and Focus on the Family Citizen Link have written about this ruling as well.








5 Comments and Trackbacks
posted by Momma2theMax on Nov. 4, 2005 at 8:24 AM
my dh told me of this story last night...he looks like slowly he's coming around to see that what hee's always accepted as "normal" and "okay" is finally coming into question...and he's seeing the established norms of secular life as less and less attractive. while this ia a bad thing for alot of people at least they are finally making the judgements and "coming out" of the closet and are not trying to be as "stealthy" anymore....because where there is light darkness cannot exist.
posted by 4Blessings on Nov. 4, 2005 at 3:35 PM
I just got off the phone with my Dh and we were talking about this. What is this world coming to? I am shocked almost on a daily basis how terrible things are becoming in the PS system. I am so glad we homeschool our children. I wouldn't have it any other way!!! Thanks for your article.
Thanks for visiting my blog. I am visiting yours for the first time and it is just lovely. Your family is also lovely.
Jennifer
posted by spunkyhomeschool on Nov. 4, 2005 at 3:45 PM
What I keep wondering Jennifer is when are the Christians going to realize that the state does not have their children's best interest in mind. The world is acting like the world. That is not a surprise. But when Christians knowing place their children under this authority what does that say?
posted by Anonymous on Nov. 5, 2005 at 2:23 AM
As a former public school teacher, my experience was that our schools never wanted to rock the boat and upset the parents. The schools to some degree respected parental authority. Unfortunately it seems like that respect is a thing of the past and after reading Chris Klicka's Homeschooling: The Right Choice, I suppose that the public schools have had a hidden agenda all along.
Here's a quote from my local support group's website -
"Parents give up their rights when they drop the children off at public school."
-- Melinda Harmon, Federal Judge, 1996
posted by spunkyhomeschool on Nov. 5, 2005 at 8:46 AM
If you read the second quote from the court opinion that I posted these judges say the same thing.
It's so sad that parents don't see what's going on. And even worse if they do see and still do nothing.